: Identifying patients' advantageous radiotherapy modalities prior to CT simulation is challenging. This study aimed to develop a workflow using deep learning (DL)-predicted synthetic CT (sCT) for treatment modality comparison based solely on a diagnostic CT (dCT). : A DL network, U-Net, was trained utilizing 46 thoracic cases from a public database to generate sCT images predicting planning CT (pCT) scans based on the latest dCT, and tested on 15 institutional patients. The sCT accuracy was evaluated against the corresponding pCT and a commercial algorithm deformed CT (MdCT) based on Mean Absolute Error (MAE) and Universal Quality Index (UQI). To determine advantageous treatment modality, clinical dose-volume histogram (DVH) metrics and Normal Tissue Complication Probability (NTCP) differences between proton and photon treatment plans were analyzed on the sCTs via concordance correlation coefficient (CCC). : The AI-generated sCTs closely resembled those of the commercial deformation algorithm in the tested cases. The differences in MAE and UQI values between the sCT-vs-pCT and MdCT-vs-pCT were 19.38 HU and 0.06, respectively. The mean absolute NTCP deviation between sCT and pCT was 1.54%, 0.21%, and 2.36% for esophagus perforation, lung pneumonitis, and heart pericarditis, respectively. The CCC between sCT and pCT was 0.90 for DVH metrics and 0.97 for NTCP, indicating moderate agreement for DVH metrics and substantial agreement. : Radiation oncologists can potentially utilize this personalized sCT based approach as a clinical support tool to rapidly compare the treatment modality benefit during patient consultation and facilitate in-depth discussion on potential toxicities at a patient-specific level.