Decke Jasmin, Seifert Roland
Institute of Pharmacology, Hannover Medical School, Carl-Neuberg-Str. 1, 30625, Hannover, Germany.
Naunyn Schmiedebergs Arch Pharmacol. 2025 May 17. doi: 10.1007/s00210-025-04248-y.
The common cold and other flu-like illnesses are the leading cause of absence from work for adults and absence from school for children. Especially during the winter people look for an easily available and reliable way of preventing colds. Many studies have been performed on the effects of vitamin C on the common cold, and some studies have been conducted on the potential link between high doses of vitamin C and adverse effects such as kidney stones. This analysis aims to gather the available information on both beneficial and adverse effects and compare these findings to the current market of vitamin C-containing supplements. To get an accurate picture, this analysis was conducted to examine the market of vitamin C supplements further and inspect the labeling, dose, cost, and advertisement of 106 selected preparations sold by online stores in Germany and the USA. The goal was to determine what benefits and risks consumers can expect when taking the available products and if they are sufficiently informed by manufacturers. The mean daily therapy cost of vitamin C across all products was $ 0.37 for a mean daily dose of 613.9 mg. The recommended daily dose of vitamin C for adults is 90 to 110 mg and 100% bioavailability is reached from doses of 100 to 400 mg. Overall safety concerns were present among products from both Germany and the USA. For instance, more than three quarters of products exceed the recommended daily dose for vitamin C-containing dietary supplements and nearly 40% of all preparations transgress a potential upper safety level. Additionally, there were some issues with product labeling, as 12 to 14% of products from Germany and 5 to 20% of products from the USA were missing warnings that are legally required or recommended. Monopreparations were generally more popular than combination preparations. However, more than one-third of all products contained other active ingredients besides vitamin C which might increase the risk of overdoses especially if paired with other dietary supplements or multivitamins. While 80% of all products advertise vitamin C to boost the immune system, the benefits in regard to the common cold are slim, as regular vitamin C supplementation fails to lower the incidence of colds among the healthy general public. Adverse effects of even high doses of vitamin C are rare but caution is advised for people with limited kidney function or patients who have previously dealt with kidney stones. The mean daily doses of the products in this analysis will likely not lead to adverse effects among the healthy general public but might be unsafe for people who have experienced kidney stones before. In conclusion, the daily doses taken in the form of vitamin C supplements are often high, and consumers are not informed properly.
普通感冒和其他流感样疾病是成年人缺勤和儿童缺课的主要原因。特别是在冬季,人们在寻找一种容易获得且可靠的预防感冒的方法。关于维生素C对普通感冒的影响已经进行了许多研究,并且也有一些关于高剂量维生素C与诸如肾结石等不良反应之间潜在联系的研究。本分析旨在收集有关维生素C有益和有害影响的现有信息,并将这些发现与当前含维生素C补充剂的市场情况进行比较。为了获得准确的情况,进行了这项分析以进一步研究维生素C补充剂市场,并检查德国和美国在线商店出售的106种选定制剂的标签、剂量、成本和广告。目的是确定消费者服用现有产品时可能预期的益处和风险,以及制造商是否向他们提供了充分的信息。所有产品中维生素C的平均每日治疗成本为0.37美元,平均每日剂量为613.9毫克。成年人维生素C的推荐每日剂量为90至110毫克,从100至400毫克的剂量可达到100%的生物利用度。德国和美国的产品都存在总体安全问题。例如,超过四分之三的产品超过了含维生素C膳食补充剂的推荐每日剂量,并且几乎40%的制剂超过了潜在的安全上限。此外,产品标签也存在一些问题,因为德国12%至14%的产品和美国5%至20%的产品缺少法律要求或推荐的警告。单一制剂通常比复方制剂更受欢迎。然而,超过三分之一 的产品除了维生素C之外还含有其他活性成分,这可能会增加过量服用的风险,特别是如果与其他膳食补充剂或多种维生素一起服用。虽然80%的产品宣传维生素C可增强免疫系统,但对于普通感冒的益处微乎其微,因为定期补充维生素C并不能降低健康普通人群中感冒的发病率。即使是高剂量的维生素C,其不良反应也很少见,但对于肾功能有限的人或以前患过肾结石的患者,建议谨慎使用。本分析中产品的平均每日剂量可能不会对健康普通人群产生不良反应,但对于以前患过肾结石的人可能不安全。总之,以维生素C补充剂形式服用的每日剂量通常很高,并且消费者没有得到适当的告知。