Kilani Ramzi A
Department of Pediatrics and Family Practice, University of Illinois at Chicago (UIC), Peoria, Illinois, USA.
J Family Med Prim Care. 2025 Apr;14(4):1174-1178. doi: 10.4103/jfmpc.jfmpc_852_24. Epub 2025 Apr 25.
The American Academy of Pediatrics (AAP) recommends providing adequate analgesia during circumcision. Ring block is the most effective method of analgesia, while topical crème (EMLA: lidocaine and prilocaine topical) alone is ineffective. We conducted a quality improvement (QI) project. The aim was to reduce pain scores and restraint duration during circumcision by 20% from baseline over six months.
We followed the standard QI process using PDSA cycles and standard QI charts.
Our preintervention data over six weeks revealed significantly higher pain scores if residents performed the procedure or if EMLA was used compared to nerve block. Our intervention included but was not limited to having a new policy to stop using EMLA and have residents watch a video on ring block before performing the procedure. Data collected over subsequent 3.5 months showed that the mean restraint time was reduced by 29% by attendings and by 15% by residents, the use of EMLA cream was eliminated, mean pain score was reduced by 82% when performed by residents and by 20% by attendings, and pain score above 3 was reduced by 100% by residents and attendings. We conducted a sustainability phase over two months. We demonstrated the sustainability of reduced restraint time among attendings but to a lesser extent among residents and the sustainability of mean pain score among both.
We conclude that improving effective analgesia during circumcision can be achieved and sustained using the QI project.
美国儿科学会(AAP)建议在包皮环切术中提供充分的镇痛。环形阻滞是最有效的镇痛方法,而单独使用外用乳膏(复方利多卡因乳膏:利多卡因和丙胺卡因外用)无效。我们开展了一项质量改进(QI)项目。目标是在六个月内将包皮环切术中的疼痛评分和约束时间较基线水平降低20%。
我们遵循使用计划-实施-检查-处理(PDSA)循环和标准QI图表的标准QI流程。
我们六周的干预前数据显示,与神经阻滞相比,如果住院医师进行该操作或使用复方利多卡因乳膏,则疼痛评分显著更高。我们的干预措施包括但不限于制定一项停止使用复方利多卡因乳膏的新政策,并让住院医师在进行该操作前观看关于环形阻滞的视频。在随后3.5个月收集的数据显示,主治医师使平均约束时间减少了29%,住院医师使平均约束时间减少了15%,复方利多卡因乳膏的使用被消除,住院医师进行操作时平均疼痛评分降低了82%,主治医师进行操作时平均疼痛评分降低了20%,住院医师和主治医师使疼痛评分高于3分的情况减少了100%。我们进行了为期两个月的可持续性阶段。我们证明了主治医师减少约束时间的可持续性,但住院医师的可持续性程度较低,并且两者的平均疼痛评分均具有可持续性。
我们得出结论,使用QI项目可以实现并维持包皮环切术中有效镇痛的改善。