Deja Monika, Zając-Lamparska Ludmiła, Trempała Janusz
Faculty of Psychology, Kazimierz Wielki University, Bydgoszcz, Poland.
Front Public Health. 2025 May 6;13:1499924. doi: 10.3389/fpubh.2025.1499924. eCollection 2025.
In recent years, research on the effectiveness of cognitive training has become increasingly popular. These studies are conducted across all age groups, including both typically developing individuals and those from clinical populations. However, their results remain inconclusive. The purpose of the present study was to verify the effectiveness of executive attention (EA) training for children in the period of middle childhood and of the transfer of the training effects onto non-trained tasks engaging working memory (WM) and fluid intelligence (Gf). The sample consisted of 180 typically developing children from two age groups: 4- and 6-year-olds. The children were divided into three research groups: the Training Group (EA training, 14 sessions), the Active Control Group (naming objects, 14 sessions), and the Passive Control Group (lack of activity). In the Training Group, the computer version of the adaptive EA training was used. WM and Gf were assessed in each group in the pre-test and post-test. The obtained data indicate the existence of asymmetry in the scope of training effects. EA training leads to a higher improvement in the correctness of performing tasks in 6-year-old children than in 4-year-old children ( = 11.603; < 0.001; η2p = 0.167). On the other hand, the transfer effect on Gf is greater in the group of 4-year-olds compared to 6-year-olds ( = 4.278; = 0.015; η2p = 0.047), and the scope of transfer to WM is the same in both age groups ( = 0.772; = 0.464; η2p = 0.009). The obtained results indicate the effectiveness of executive attention training in children in these age groups. The results suggest that older children benefit more from practicing specific cognitive skills. In comparison, the far transfer mechanisms of training effects seem stronger in younger children.
近年来,认知训练有效性的研究越来越受欢迎。这些研究针对所有年龄组进行,包括发育正常的个体和临床人群中的个体。然而,其结果仍无定论。本研究的目的是验证执行性注意力(EA)训练对童年中期儿童的有效性,以及训练效果向涉及工作记忆(WM)和流体智力(Gf)的未训练任务的迁移情况。样本由来自两个年龄组的180名发育正常的儿童组成:4岁和6岁儿童。这些儿童被分为三个研究组:训练组(EA训练,14节课程)、主动对照组(物体命名,14节课程)和被动对照组(无活动)。在训练组中,使用了计算机版的适应性EA训练。在每组的预测试和后测试中对WM和Gf进行评估。获得的数据表明训练效果范围存在不对称性。EA训练使6岁儿童执行任务的正确性提高幅度高于4岁儿童( = 11.603; < 0.001;η2p = 0.167)。另一方面,4岁儿童组对Gf的迁移效果比6岁儿童组更大( = 4.278; = 0.015;η2p = 0.047),且两个年龄组向WM的迁移范围相同( = 0.772; = 0.464;η2p = 0.009)。获得的结果表明这些年龄组儿童的执行性注意力训练是有效的。结果表明年龄较大的儿童从练习特定认知技能中受益更多。相比之下,训练效果的远迁移机制在年龄较小的儿童中似乎更强。