Elasser Dalia M, Sobhy Sabah M, Taha Rania Rashad Omar, Gad Nevin A, Abdel-Ghany Dina M
Operative Dentistry Department, Faculty of Dental Medicine for Girls, Al-Azhar University, Cairo, Egypt.
Endodontics Department, Faculty of Dental Medicine for Girls, Al-Azhar University, Cairo, Egypt.
Saudi Dent J. 2025 May 10;37(4-6):7. doi: 10.1007/s44445-025-00009-y.
This study compared the efficacy of nanopropolis and nanocurcumin as direct pulp-capping agents to that of mineral trioxide aggregate (MTA) in recently erupted permanent molars, assessing the clinical and radiographic outcomes over six months. Thirty six permanent molars were randomly allocated to three groups (n = 12 each): MTA (control), nanopropolis and nanocurcumin. The study followed a double-blind design. Clinical and radiological evaluations assessed pain, percussion sensitivity and swelling preoperatively and one week, three months and six months afterwards. At one week, the nanocurcumin group showed significantly higher pain levels than the MTA and nanopropolis groups. The pain scores equalised by three months and remained stable until six months in all groups. Percussion sensitivity and swelling occurred in 8.3% of cases in the MTA group, 25% in the nanopropolis group and 16.7% in the nanocurcumin group. Nanopropolis and nanocurcumin provided clinical and radiographic outcomes comparable to MTA in direct pulp capping of recently erupted permanent molars. While MTA showed slightly superior attributes, the natural nanomaterials present viable alternatives. This study supports the potential use of bioactive nanomaterials derived from natural sources in vital pulp therapy, though longer-term investigations are warranted.
本研究比较了纳米ropolis和纳米姜黄素作为直接盖髓剂与矿物三氧化物凝聚体(MTA)在近期萌出的恒牙磨牙中的疗效,评估了六个月内的临床和影像学结果。三十六颗恒牙磨牙被随机分为三组(每组n = 12):MTA(对照组)、纳米ropolis组和纳米姜黄素组。该研究采用双盲设计。临床和放射学评估在术前以及术后一周、三个月和六个月时评估疼痛、叩诊敏感性和肿胀情况。在一周时,纳米姜黄素组的疼痛水平显著高于MTA组和纳米ropolis组。三个月时疼痛评分趋于相等,且在所有组中直至六个月时都保持稳定。MTA组8.3%的病例出现叩诊敏感性和肿胀,纳米ropolis组为25%,纳米姜黄素组为16.7%。在近期萌出的恒牙磨牙直接盖髓中,纳米ropolis和纳米姜黄素提供了与MTA相当的临床和影像学结果。虽然MTA表现出稍优越的特性,但天然纳米材料是可行的替代物。本研究支持在活髓治疗中使用源自天然来源的生物活性纳米材料的潜力,不过仍需要进行长期研究。