Khakban Iliya, Jain Shagun, Gallab Joseph, Dharmaraj Blossom, Zhou Fangwen, Lokker Cynthia, Abdelkader Wael, Zeraatkar Dena, Busse Jason W
McMaster University, Hamilton, ON, Canada.
J Med Internet Res. 2025 May 21;27:e65087. doi: 10.2196/65087.
BACKGROUND: Myalgic encephalomyelitis (ME), also referred to as chronic fatigue syndrome (CFS), is a complex illness that typically presents with disabling fatigue and cognitive and functional impairment. The etiology and management of ME/CFS remain contentious and patients often describe their experiences through social media. OBJECTIVE: We explored public discourse on Twitter (rebranded as X) to understand the concerns and priorities of individuals living with ME/CFS, with a focus on (1) the COVID-19 pandemic and (2) publication of the 2021 UK National Institute for Health and Care Excellence (NICE) guidelines on the diagnosis and management of ME/CFS. METHODS: We used the Twitter application programming interface to collect tweets related to ME/CFS posted between January 1, 2010, and January 30, 2024. Tweets were sorted into 3 chronological periods (pre-COVID-19 pandemic, post-COVID-19 pandemic, and post-UK 2021 NICE Guidelines publication). A Robustly Optimized Bidirectional Embedding Representations from Transformers Pretraining Approach (RoBERTa) language processing model was used to categorize the sentiment of tweets as positive, negative, or neutral. We identified tweets that mentioned COVID-19, the UK NICE guidelines, and key themes identified through latent Dirichlet allocation (ie, fibromyalgia, research, and treatment). We sampled 1000 random tweets from each theme to identify subthemes and representative quotes. RESULTS: We retrieved 906,404 tweets, of which 427,824 (47.2%) were neutral, 369,371 (40.75%) were negative, and 109,209 (12.05%) were positive. Over time, both the proportion of negative and positive tweets increased, and the proportion of neutral tweets decreased (P<.001 for all changes). Tweets mentioning fibromyalgia acknowledged similarities with ME/CFS, stigmatization associated with both disorders, and lack of effective treatments. Treatment-related tweets often described frustration with ME/CFS labeled as mental illness, dismissal of concerns by health care providers, and the need to seek out "good physicians" who viewed ME/CFS as a physical disorder. Tweets on research typically praised studies of biomarkers and biomedical therapies, called for greater investment in biomedical research, and expressed frustration with studies suggesting a biopsychosocial etiology for ME/CFS or supporting management with psychotherapy or graduated activity. Tweets about the UK NICE guidelines expressed frustration with the 2007 version that recommended cognitive behavioral therapy and graded exercise therapy, and a prolonged campaign by advocacy organizations to influence subsequent versions. Tweets showed high acceptance of the 2021 UK NICE guidelines, which were seen to validate ME/CFS as a biomedical disease and recommended against graded exercise therapy. Tweets about COVID-19 often noted overlaps between post-COVID-19 condition and ME/CFS, including claims of a common biological pathway, and advised there was no cure for either condition. CONCLUSIONS: Our findings suggest research is needed to inform how best to support patients' engagement with evidence-based care. Furthermore, while patient involvement with ME/CFS research is critical, unmanaged intellectual conflicts of interest may threaten the trustworthiness of research efforts.
背景:肌痛性脑脊髓炎(ME),也被称为慢性疲劳综合征(CFS),是一种复杂的疾病,通常表现为使人衰弱的疲劳以及认知和功能障碍。ME/CFS的病因和管理仍存在争议,患者经常通过社交媒体描述他们的经历。 目的:我们在推特(现更名为X)上探索公众话语,以了解ME/CFS患者的关注点和优先事项,重点关注(1)新冠疫情,以及(2)2021年英国国家卫生与临床优化研究所(NICE)发布的ME/CFS诊断和管理指南。 方法:我们使用推特应用程序编程接口收集了2010年1月1日至2024年1月30日期间发布的与ME/CFS相关的推文。推文被分为三个按时间顺序排列的时期(新冠疫情前、新冠疫情后、英国2021年NICE指南发布后)。使用一种基于预训练的来自变换器的稳健优化双向嵌入表示法(RoBERTa)语言处理模型将推文的情感分类为积极、消极或中性。我们识别出提及新冠疫情、英国NICE指南以及通过潜在狄利克雷分配确定的关键主题(即纤维肌痛、研究和治疗)的推文。我们从每个主题中随机抽取1000条推文以确定子主题和代表性引述。 结果:我们检索到906,404条推文,其中427,824条(47.2%)为中性,369,371条(40.75%)为消极,109,209条(12.05%)为积极。随着时间的推移,消极和积极推文的比例都有所增加,而中性推文的比例则下降(所有变化的P<0.0)。提及纤维肌痛的推文承认其与ME/CFS的相似之处、与这两种疾病相关的污名化以及缺乏有效治疗方法。与治疗相关的推文经常描述对被标记为精神疾病的ME/CFS的沮丧、医疗保健提供者对担忧的忽视,以及寻找将ME/CFS视为身体疾病的“好医生”的必要性。关于研究的推文通常赞扬生物标志物和生物医学疗法的研究,呼吁加大对生物医学研究的投资,并对表明ME/CFS具有生物心理社会病因或支持心理治疗或分级活动管理的研究表示沮丧。关于英国NICE指南的推文对2007年推荐认知行为疗法和分级运动疗法的版本表示沮丧,以及倡导组织为影响后续版本而进行的长期活动。推文对2021年英国NICE指南表示高度认可,该指南被视为将ME/CFS确认为一种生物医学疾病并反对分级运动疗法。关于新冠疫情的推文经常指出新冠后状况与ME/CFS之间的重叠,包括声称存在共同的生物学途径,并表示这两种状况都无法治愈。 结论:我们的研究结果表明,需要开展研究以告知如何最好地支持患者参与循证护理。此外,虽然患者参与ME/CFS研究至关重要,但未得到管理的利益冲突可能会威胁到研究工作的可信度。
BMJ. 2025-1-22
JAMA Netw Open. 2024-4-1
BMJ Open. 2024-1-29
Scand J Prim Health Care. 2023-12