Jain Dipty, Seth Tulika, Udupi Shashank, Jain Suman, Bhatwadekar Seema, Menon Nandakumar, Jena Rabindra, Kumar Ravindra, Parmar Bharat, Goel Anil, Vasava Ashvin, Dutta Anupam, Samal Priyanka, Ballikar Riya, Bhat Deepa, Dolai Tuphan Kanti, Bhattacharyya Jina, Shetty Disha, Mistry Manish, Ray Shomik
Arihant Education and Research Foundation, Nagpur, Maharashtra, India.
All India Institute of Medical Sciences, New Delhi, Delhi, India.
BMJ Glob Health. 2025 May 22;10(5):e017887. doi: 10.1136/bmjgh-2024-017887.
Sickle cell disease (SCD) with vaso-occlusive pain crisis (VOC) has a major impact on healthcare resource utilisation and poses a significant financial burden for the patients. This study examines the economic implications of managing VOC in individuals with SCD in India, from the perspectives of patients, healthcare system and society.
This cross-sectional, observational study included 1000 patients with SCD across 14 centres enrolled from November 2021 to June 2022. Data were collected systematically using a structured electronic case record form. Employing a cost-of-illness approach, the study assessed the economic impact of SCD and VOC management, including assessing patient/caregiver costs, healthcare provider costs and societal burdens extrapolated to the larger SCD population in India.
Patients incurred substantial out-of-pocket expenses, with a median (IQR) annual expenditure of INR 22 080/US$267 (IQR: INR 36 990/US$447.7), representing 14.65% (26.53) of their annual household income. Overall, catastrophic healthcare expenditure (CHE) for total annual average SCD care with VOC management was experienced by 624 patients (62.40%). Moreover, 334 patients (33.4%) experienced CHE of >25% of the annual household income. Patients with SCD with VOC had significantly higher median annual healthcare expenditures and used a higher median percentage of their yearly household income on healthcare compared with those without VOC (19.82% vs 6.08%; p<0.001). Cost incurred by healthcare providers for VOC management in different healthcare facilities (outpatient department/emergency department/intensive care unit) was similar across different reimbursed facilities (government tertiary care hospitals, non-governmental organisation-operated healthcare centres and government-subsidised healthcare setups). The estimated societal burden for VOC management in 1 year for 1000 patients visiting different healthcare facilities was around INR 35 119 074 (~US$0.42 million).
These findings highlight the considerable economic strain on both patients and healthcare providers in SCD and VOC management, which is similar to the other non-communicable diseases emphasising the urgent need for targeted interventions to improve financial hardships among patients.
The study was funded by Novartis Healthcare Private Limited.
镰状细胞病(SCD)伴血管闭塞性疼痛危象(VOC)对医疗资源利用有重大影响,并给患者带来巨大经济负担。本研究从患者、医疗系统和社会的角度,考察了印度SCD患者管理VOC的经济影响。
这项横断面观察性研究纳入了2021年11月至2022年6月期间从14个中心招募的1000例SCD患者。使用结构化电子病例记录表单系统收集数据。采用疾病成本法,该研究评估了SCD和VOC管理的经济影响,包括评估患者/照顾者成本、医疗服务提供者成本以及推算至印度更大SCD人群的社会负担。
患者自付费用高昂,年支出中位数(IQR)为22080印度卢比/267美元(IQR:36990印度卢比/447.7美元),占其家庭年收入的14.65%(26.53)。总体而言,624例患者(62.40%)经历了SCD合并VOC管理的年度总平均灾难性医疗支出(CHE)。此外,334例患者(33.4%)经历了CHE超过家庭年收入的25%。与无VOC的患者相比,SCD合并VOC的患者年度医疗支出中位数显著更高,且医疗支出占家庭年收入的中位数百分比更高(19.82%对6.08%;p<0.001)。不同报销机构(政府三级医院、非政府组织运营的医疗中心和政府补贴的医疗机构)中,不同医疗设施(门诊部/急诊科/重症监护室)的医疗服务提供者管理VOC的成本相似。1000例前往不同医疗设施就诊的患者1年中VOC管理的估计社会负担约为35119074印度卢比(约42万美元)。
这些发现凸显了SCD和VOC管理给患者和医疗服务提供者带来的巨大经济压力,这与其他非传染性疾病相似,强调迫切需要有针对性的干预措施来改善患者的经济困境。
本研究由诺华医疗保健私人有限公司资助。