Ebinim Hilda, Olatunji Oluwadamilare, Samuel Olugbemisola, Oluwatola Toluwani, Hoemeke Laura, Chenge Charity, Otu Emediong, Orbunde Terver, Omanukwue Miriamtherese, Sampson Sidney
Sydani Initiative for International Development, FCT, Abuja, Nigeria.
Sydani Institute for Research and Innovation, FCT, Abuja, Nigeria.
Discov Health Syst. 2025;4(1):59. doi: 10.1007/s44250-025-00239-1. Epub 2025 May 27.
This study addresses the needs of skilled birth attendants (SBAs) of primary healthcare centers (PHCs) in Nigeria using the human resources for health (HRH) solutions model. A model analysis approach was adopted to understand existing frameworks in the global HRH landscape. An initial framework identification and contextualization were conducted to guide the analysis of the models identified in the literature. Relevant frameworks were identified, reviewed, and consolidated using the WHO HRH Action Framework (HAF). A total of 109 articles were included in the study after thorough screening out of which only nine (9) models of improving HRH planning and implementation in global health were reviewed. These were the Task Shifting/Sharing Model, Community Midwifery Model (CMM), Performance-Based Financing Model (PBF), Needs-Based Planning Model, Facilities-Based HRH Planning Model, Utilization-Based HRH Planning Model, Workforce Indicator Staffing Needs Model, USAID-Financing Innovations for Nutrition (FINFI) Model, and Micro-Learning Model. The proposed HRH solution model was adapted based on the gaps identified in all analyzed models. This study showed that there are different HRH models which address specific elements of the HRH value chain. However, these models are not comprehensive, therefore, tackling the challenges of SBA shortage in Nigeria would either require the integration of multiple models or the deployment of models in a phased approach which is what informed the proposed HRH solution model in addressing SBAs' needs of PHCs in Nigeria. We therefore recommend the implementation of the model.
本研究采用卫生人力资源(HRH)解决方案模型,以满足尼日利亚初级卫生保健中心(PHCs)熟练助产士(SBAs)的需求。采用模型分析方法来了解全球卫生人力资源领域的现有框架。进行了初步的框架识别和情境化,以指导对文献中确定的模型进行分析。使用世界卫生组织卫生人力资源行动框架(HAF)识别、审查和整合相关框架。经过全面筛选,共有109篇文章纳入本研究,其中仅对全球卫生领域改善卫生人力资源规划和实施的9种模型进行了审查。这些模型分别是任务转移/分担模型、社区助产模型(CMM)、基于绩效的融资模型(PBF)、基于需求的规划模型、基于设施的卫生人力资源规划模型、基于利用的卫生人力资源规划模型、劳动力指标人员配置需求模型、美国国际开发署营养融资创新(FINFI)模型和微学习模型。根据所有分析模型中发现的差距,对提议的卫生人力资源解决方案模型进行了调整。本研究表明,有不同的卫生人力资源模型可解决卫生人力资源价值链的特定要素。然而,这些模型并不全面,因此,应对尼日利亚熟练助产士短缺的挑战,要么需要整合多种模型,要么需要分阶段部署模型,这就是提议的卫生人力资源解决方案模型用以满足尼日利亚初级卫生保健中心熟练助产士需求的依据。因此,我们建议实施该模型。