Gariti Alexander, Berkman Emily, Clark Jonna, Derrington Sabrina, Dudzinski Denise, Madrigal Vanessa, Mann David, Walter Jennifer, Wolfe Ian
Texas Children's, Baylor College of Medicine, Houston, Texas, USA.
Seattle Children's, University of Washington, Seattle, Washington, USA.
Pediatr Transplant. 2025 Aug;29(5):e70101. doi: 10.1111/petr.70101.
The scarcity of transplantable organs has led to the development of normothermic regional perfusion (NRP) to enhance organ viability and supply. While NRP offers promise to increase the quality and quantity of transplantable organs, its implementation raises significant ethical concerns regarding the Dead Donor Rule (DDR), consent/authorization, and physician participation. These concerns are further magnified in pediatric organ donation given such patients' increased vulnerability and lack of decision-making authority. While arguments continue to play out in the literature, several OPOs in the US perform NRP and are requesting institutions to implement this practice. As pediatric ethicists, our aim is to create guidelines for the ethical implementation of NRP in pediatric donors. We highlight the challenges regarding the DDR, discuss requirements for informed consent, outline a thoughtful approach for engaging with families during crises, and address conscientious objections for clinicians who are morally apprehensive about participating in NRP. We recommend collaboration with hospital/organizational leadership, transplant programs, organ procurement organizations, and clinical ethicists to collaboratively plan to address these ethical controversies at the institutional level. Use of a pre-NRP checklist may help ensure that all potential donor families and patients are treated with respect and fully informed about the process and that there is sufficient education of and support for clinicians who participate in NRP. If institutions and OPOs collaborate to implement these guidelines, they will ensure that they honor donors and their families without negatively impacting public trust in organ donation, increase organ supply and viability, and ultimately improve outcomes for transplant recipients.
可移植器官的稀缺促使常温局部灌注(NRP)技术的发展,以提高器官的存活率和供应量。虽然NRP有望提高可移植器官的质量和数量,但其实施引发了关于死亡捐献者规则(DDR)、同意/授权以及医生参与等重大伦理问题。鉴于儿科患者的脆弱性增加且缺乏决策能力,这些问题在儿科器官捐赠中更加突出。尽管相关争论在文献中仍在持续,但美国的几家器官获取组织(OPO)正在开展NRP,并要求各机构采用这种做法。作为儿科伦理学家,我们的目标是制定关于在儿科供体中伦理实施NRP的指南。我们强调了DDR方面的挑战,讨论了知情同意的要求,概述了在危机期间与家庭沟通的周全方法,并处理了对参与NRP存在道德顾虑的临床医生的良心反对问题。我们建议与医院/组织领导、移植项目、器官获取组织以及临床伦理学家合作,共同计划在机构层面解决这些伦理争议。使用NRP前检查表可能有助于确保所有潜在的供体家庭和患者都受到尊重,并充分了解该过程,同时确保参与NRP的临床医生得到充分的培训和支持。如果各机构和OPO合作实施这些指南,将确保他们尊重捐赠者及其家人,同时不会对公众对器官捐赠的信任产生负面影响,增加器官供应和存活率,并最终改善移植受者的结局。