Pandya Himanshu, Varma Jagdish, Ghosh Sarmistha, Kumar Dinesh, Prabhakaran Anusha, Prakash R Harihara
Department of Medicine and Medical Education, Pramukhswami Medical College, Bhaikaka University, Anand, India.
Department of Psychiatry, Pramukhswami Medical College, Bhaikaka University, Anand, India.
Front Med (Lausanne). 2025 May 19;12:1544761. doi: 10.3389/fmed.2025.1544761. eCollection 2025.
Healthcare is inherently human-centered, and professionalism is crucial for improving healthcare systems. Traditionally developed through role modeling, professionalism now necessitates explicit teaching. Despite the inclusion of professionalism-related competencies by Indian regulatory bodies in medicine and nursing, its structured teaching remains limited. To address this, we introduced concepts of Professionalism and Professional Identity Formation (PIF) to newly joined faculty at our university, following established frameworks. This report details the workshop process and key lessons learned.
A six-member core faculty team with expertise in health professions education conducted a daylong workshop. The morning session focused on contemporary perspectives on professionalism, while the afternoon session addressed PIF. Anonymous post-session feedback was collected via Google Forms, with quantitative responses rated on a five-point Likert scale and qualitative feedback analyzed using Braun and Clarke's six-phase thematic analysis.
Three workshops were held in June 2024 for faculty who had joined over the past 2 years. Attendance across the three sessions was 25, 23, and 24 participants, respectively, from medicine, physiotherapy, nursing, and allied health disciplines. Response rates for feedback were 80% ( = 20), 43% ( = 10), and 45% ( = 11). Fifty percent ( = 21) reported high satisfaction, 41% ( = 16) moderate, and 7% ( = 3) low. Participants noted shifts in their perceptions, recognizing professionalism as a learned skill rather than an inherent trait. Key takeaways included the significance of effective communication, empathy, and resilience in shaping professional identity. In terms of educational impact, participants intended to model professionalism, reinforce positive behaviors, and explicitly integrate PIF into their teaching. Proposed strategies included experiential learning, structured orientation, and active learning methods. The workshop was appreciated for its interactive elements, such as group discussions, case-based learning, and open forums. However, areas for improvement included better time management, concise delivery, enhanced multimedia use, and more structured engagement. Participants also suggested extending the workshop to resident doctors and a mixed audience of residents and consultants.
The workshop effectively conveyed professionalism and PIF concepts. Future iterations could benefit from refinements in structure and delivery, as well as audience expansion. Our experience may guide similar faculty development initiatives in other healthcare institutions.
医疗保健本质上是以人为主的,专业精神对于改善医疗保健系统至关重要。传统上,专业精神是通过榜样示范培养的,如今则需要进行明确的教学。尽管印度监管机构已将与专业精神相关的能力纳入医学和护理领域,但针对其的结构化教学仍然有限。为解决这一问题,我们按照既定框架,向我校新入职的教师介绍了专业精神和专业身份形成(PIF)的概念。本报告详细介绍了研讨会过程及主要经验教训。
一个由六名在卫生专业教育方面具有专业知识的核心教师团队举办了为期一天的研讨会。上午的会议聚焦于专业精神的当代观点,下午的会议则讨论了PIF。通过谷歌表单收集匿名的会后反馈,定量回答采用五点李克特量表评分,定性反馈则使用布劳恩和克拉克的六阶段主题分析法进行分析。
2024年6月为过去两年内入职的教师举办了三场研讨会。三场会议的参会人员分别来自医学、物理治疗、护理和相关健康学科,人数分别为25人、23人和24人。反馈的回复率分别为80%(n = 20)、43%(n = 10)和45%(n = 11)。50%(n = 21)的人表示高度满意,41%(n = 16)的人表示中等满意,7%(n = 3)的人表示不满意。参与者指出他们的观念发生了转变,并认识到专业精神是一种习得的技能而非固有特质。关键收获包括有效沟通、同理心和适应力在塑造专业身份中的重要性。在教育影响方面,参与者打算树立专业精神榜样,强化积极行为,并将PIF明确融入他们的教学中。提议的策略包括体验式学习、结构化入职培训和主动学习方法。研讨会因其互动元素,如小组讨论、基于案例的学习和开放论坛而受到好评。然而,需要改进的方面包括更好的时间管理、简洁的授课、增强多媒体的使用以及更结构化的参与。参与者还建议将研讨会扩展至住院医生以及住院医生和顾问的混合群体。
该研讨会有效地传达了专业精神和PIF的概念。未来的研讨会可从结构和授课方式的改进以及受众扩展中受益。我们的经验可能会为其他医疗保健机构的类似教师发展计划提供指导。