de Barros Sandra Garrido, Rossi Thais Regis Aranha, de Rebouças Carvalho Ana Clara, Cruz Denise Nogueira, de Santana Sisse Figueiredo, Reis Camila Ramos, Magno Laio, Dourado Inês, Vieira-da-Silva Ligia Maria
Faculty of Dentistry, Federal University of Bahia, Rua Araújo Pinho, 62, Canela, Salvador, Bahia, CEP: 40.110-912, Brazil.
Collective Health Institute of Federal University of Bahia, Salvador, Bahia,, Brazil.
BMC Public Health. 2025 Jun 5;25(1):2101. doi: 10.1186/s12889-025-23229-7.
Considering the potential role of primary health care (PHC) in the response to COVID-19, a formative evaluation (FE) was carried out between December 2021 and February 2022 to understand its work process against COVID-19 in a high-vulnerability health district in Brazil, identifying the difficulties in carrying out tests and the best practices for the implementation of the intervention "Expansion of testing, quarantine, e-health and telemonitoring strategies to combat COVID-19 in Brazil" (TQT).
FEs are used to guide the implementation of health interventions. This FE was based on a situational diagnosis of the territories and PHC health units of the health district under study, with approximately 400,000 inhabitants, in which the TQT Project would later be implemented. A qualitative study was conducted based on 22 semistructured interviews and three focus groups (FGs) involving 19 PHC professionals. The interviews and FGs were analysed in terms of their thematic content.
There was a lack of coordination in implementing actions; COVID-19 testing was concentrated in a few PHC units, generating work overload and weakness of other health programs in these units; the health units' physical structure was inadequate, and human resources were insufficient; and no criteria were identified for defining the number of tests offered per day per unit.
The FE identified barriers to testing and supported the design of the TQT, including the adaptations needed to implement actions. The concentration of testing in a few units is an important barrier to access; it is suggested that testing actions should be deconcentrated in as many health units as possible.
考虑到初级卫生保健(PHC)在应对2019冠状病毒病(COVID-19)中的潜在作用,于2021年12月至2022年2月进行了一次形成性评估(FE),以了解巴西一个高脆弱性卫生区针对COVID-19的工作流程,确定开展检测的困难以及实施“扩大检测、隔离、电子健康和远程监测策略以抗击巴西的COVID-19”(TQT)干预措施的最佳做法。
形成性评估用于指导卫生干预措施的实施。本次形成性评估基于对研究中的卫生区的地域和初级卫生保健卫生单位的情况诊断,该卫生区约有40万居民,TQT项目随后将在该地区实施。基于22次半结构化访谈和涉及19名初级卫生保健专业人员的三个焦点小组(FGs)进行了一项定性研究。对访谈和焦点小组的主题内容进行了分析。
在行动实施方面缺乏协调;COVID-19检测集中在少数几个初级卫生保健单位,导致这些单位工作负担过重,其他卫生项目薄弱;卫生单位的物理结构不足,人力资源也不足;并且没有确定每个单位每天提供检测数量的标准。
形成性评估确定了检测方面的障碍,并支持了TQT的设计,包括实施行动所需的调整。检测集中在少数几个单位是获取检测的一个重要障碍;建议尽可能将检测行动分散到更多的卫生单位。