Vieira André, Ricoca Peixoto Vasco, Aguiar Pedro, Sousa Paulo, Abrantes Alexandre
Public Health Research Center, NOVA National School of Public Health, Universidade NOVA de Lisboa, Lisbon, Portugal.
Port J Public Health. 2021 May 6;38(Suppl 1):47-53. doi: 10.1159/000515656.
On March 16, 2020, the first death from CO-VID-19 was recorded in Portugal. Since then, there has been a reorganization of health services, changing the normal approach for the different cases of public health. Excess deaths recorded without a COVID-19 diagnosis are called excess mortality without COVID-19 (EM non-COVID-19). This study aims to estimate the EM non-COVID in the 7-month period after the first registered Covid-19 death.
The following 2 methods were used to estimate the excess mortality in this period: the daily historical average of reported deaths and an adapted auto regressive integrated moving average (ARIMA) model, considering the previous 5 years of records until October 16. For this model, after March 16, data was replaced with the daily historical average deaths from the previous 5 years, simulating the closest scenario possible as there was no pandemic. Only deaths from natural causes were selected for these estimations. For EM non-COVID-19 estimation, we subtracted the COVID-19 deaths from the overall excess mortality.
Between March 16, 2020, and October 16, 2020, there was an excess of 6,330 deaths from natural causes, i.e., nearly 12% more than expected. Both methods estimated an EM non-COVID-19 of around 66-67% in this period, with a greater relevance in mid-July and mid-September.
Excess mortality was present almost every day during the study period. EM non-COVID-19 seemed to vary over time, showing some inadequacy of healthcare services in management of other patients free of COVID-19 in Portugal during periods with a greater patient volume. It is necessary to take care and monitor COVID-19 cases but also non-COVID-19 cases.
2020年3月16日,葡萄牙记录了首例新冠肺炎死亡病例。自那时起,卫生服务进行了重组,改变了针对不同公共卫生病例的常规处理方式。未被诊断为新冠肺炎但记录的超额死亡被称为非新冠肺炎超额死亡率(EM非新冠肺炎)。本研究旨在估计首例登记的新冠肺炎死亡病例后的7个月期间的EM非新冠肺炎情况。
采用以下两种方法来估计该时期的超额死亡率:报告死亡人数的每日历史平均值和一个经过调整的自回归积分移动平均(ARIMA)模型,该模型考虑了截至10月16日之前的5年记录。对于该模型,3月16日之后的数据被替换为前5年的每日历史平均死亡人数,模拟在没有大流行的情况下尽可能接近的情景。这些估计仅选择自然原因导致的死亡病例。对于EM非新冠肺炎的估计,我们从总体超额死亡率中减去新冠肺炎死亡人数。
在2020年3月16日至2020年10月16日期间,自然原因导致的死亡病例超额6330例,即比预期多出近12%。两种方法在此期间估计的EM非新冠肺炎约为66%-67%,在7月中旬和9月中旬更为显著。
在研究期间,几乎每天都存在超额死亡率。EM非新冠肺炎似乎随时间变化,显示出在葡萄牙患者数量较多的时期,医疗服务在管理其他非新冠肺炎患者方面存在一些不足。有必要关注和监测新冠肺炎病例以及非新冠肺炎病例。