Yamao Shoki, Ueda Ryota, Koguchi Shoichiro, Nakase Michi, Suzuki Aru, Toyoda Kohdai, Kobayashi Ken, Nakata Kazuhide
Department of Industrial Engineering and Economics, School of Engineering, Institute of Science Tokyo, Meguro, Tokyo, Japan.
PLoS One. 2025 Jun 6;20(6):e0325173. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0325173. eCollection 2025.
In mature markets, where products are widely adopted, understanding how customers switch between competing products is crucial for companies to conduct effective marketing actions. However, due to privacy regulations, it is increasingly difficult to obtain point-of-sale (POS) data with individual customer identifiers (IDs). In this paper, we propose a method that estimates how sales shift between products using aggregated POS data without customer IDs. We formulate this as an optimal transport problem aimed at minimizing the total cost of brand-switching and introduce two regularization terms based on assumptions about sales transitions. We then solve the optimization problem with these regularizations using a projected gradient method. We validated our approach on proprietary POS data from the Japanese beverage industry and found that the estimated transitions aligned with real market changes. For instance, during a liquor tax reform period, customers switched from products whose tax rates increased to those with lower rates. In the coffee market, many customers moved toward a newly launched brand. Although these results suggest that our method can capture market dynamics, the proprietary data limits reproducibility. In addition, the absence of customer IDs makes it impossible to track individual customer transitions. Incorporating such identifiers in future research could offer more deeper insights into consumer behavior.
在产品被广泛采用的成熟市场中,了解客户如何在竞争产品之间切换,对于公司开展有效的营销行动至关重要。然而,由于隐私法规,获取带有个体客户标识符(ID)的销售点(POS)数据变得越来越困难。在本文中,我们提出了一种方法,该方法使用没有客户ID的汇总POS数据来估计产品之间的销售转移情况。我们将此表述为一个旨在最小化品牌转换总成本的最优运输问题,并基于对销售转换的假设引入两个正则化项。然后,我们使用投影梯度法求解带有这些正则化的优化问题。我们在来自日本饮料行业的专有POS数据上验证了我们的方法,发现估计的转换与实际市场变化一致。例如,在酒类税改期间,客户从税率提高的产品转向税率较低的产品。在咖啡市场,许多客户转向了新推出的品牌。尽管这些结果表明我们的方法可以捕捉市场动态,但专有数据限制了可重复性。此外,没有客户ID使得无法跟踪个体客户的转换情况。在未来研究中纳入此类标识符可以提供对消费者行为更深入的见解。