Pasha Humaira Kamal
Université Clermont Auvergne CNRS (CERDI), Clermont-Ferrand, France.
AEI International School, Université Paris-Est Créteil, Paris, France.
J Knowl Econ. 2023 Mar 22:1-46. doi: 10.1007/s13132-023-01222-y.
Differences in education between girls and boys persist in Pakistan, and the distribution of household resources and socioeconomic disparities are compounding the problem. This paper determines education attainment (primary to tertiary level) and current enrollment and explores underlying gender differences with reference to per capita income and socioeconomic characteristics of the household by using survey data of Pakistan (2005-2019) that have never been used in this context before. The potential endogeneity bias between income and education is addressed through the two-stage residual inclusion (2SRI) method that is appropriate for non-linear models used in this study. Findings indicate that income is likely to increase and facilitate a significant transition from primary- to tertiary-level education attainment. The boys have a higher likelihood to increase tertiary-level education attainment by household income. However, the probability of current enrollment is equivalent for girls and boys after controlling for endogeneity. The gender effects of Oaxaca-type decomposition indicate higher unexplained variation that describes a strong gender gap between boys and girls. The standard deviation for education inequality and gender gap ratio confirm that higher levels of discrimination and lower economic returns are associated with girls' education, and individual and community attributes favor boys' education. Findings suggest policies and educational strategies that focus on female education and lower-income households to build socioeconomic stability and sustainable human capital in the country.
在巴基斯坦,女孩和男孩在教育方面的差异依然存在,家庭资源分配和社会经济差距使这一问题更加复杂。本文利用巴基斯坦2005年至2019年此前从未在此背景下使用过的调查数据,确定教育程度(从小学到高等教育)和当前入学情况,并参照家庭人均收入和社会经济特征探究潜在的性别差异。通过适用于本研究中使用的非线性模型的两阶段残差纳入(2SRI)方法解决收入与教育之间潜在的内生性偏差问题。研究结果表明,收入可能会增加,并有助于从小学教育程度向高等教育程度实现显著转变。男孩因家庭收入而提高高等教育程度的可能性更大。然而,在控制内生性之后,女孩和男孩当前的入学概率相当。奥瓦卡类型分解的性别效应表明,无法解释的差异更大,这表明男孩和女孩之间存在很大的性别差距。教育不平等和性别差距比的标准差证实,更高程度的歧视和更低的经济回报与女孩的教育相关,而个人和社区属性则有利于男孩的教育。研究结果提出了侧重于女性教育和低收入家庭的政策及教育战略,以在该国建立社会经济稳定和可持续的人力资本。