Meshaka Riwa, Fitzke Heather E, Barber Joy, Foster Chloe, Reid Catriona, Allan Emma, Murphy Rebecca, Jones Kelsey, Taylor Stuart A, Watson Tom A
Great Ormond Street Hospital for Children NHS Foundation Trust, London, WC1N 3BH, UK.
University College London, London, UK.
Pediatr Radiol. 2025 Jun;55(7):1414-1424. doi: 10.1007/s00247-025-06273-8. Epub 2025 Jun 7.
Quantitative bowel motility in inflammatory bowel disease using magnetic resonance enterography (MRE) shows promise as a biomarker of disease activity against histopathological and biochemical markers of inflammation when used by experienced readers in a research setting.
The aim of this study was to test multi-reader agreement in quantified bowel motility by non-experienced readers.
A single-centre, retrospective search included all patients <18 years with paediatric inflammatory bowel disease and more than one MRE between 2012-2022. Cine images from the first two MREs were processed using quantified motility software. Two experienced readers provided a reference standard for response using a consensus sMaRIA (decrease of ≥2 points) and measured the change (Δ) in motility index. Two senior and three junior readers visually assessed response for each patient and recorded Δ motility index. Inter-reader agreement was assessed for each pair of readers as the Bland-Altman bias and limits of agreement for Δ motility index (arbitrary units, a.u.) and %agreement in the Δdirection.
Percentage agreement in the Δdirection was fair to excellent. Junior reader agreement with experienced readers was 73-84%, and senior reader agreement with experienced readers was 67-85%. Bland-Altman plots of Δ motility index demonstrated no systematic bias and the junior-experienced readers' limits of agreement were acceptable.
Quantified bowel motility in paediatric inflammatory bowel disease measured by readers of varied experience yields good agreement.
在炎症性肠病中,使用磁共振小肠造影(MRE)进行定量肠动力分析,对于有经验的读者在研究环境中使用时,作为疾病活动的生物标志物,相对于炎症的组织病理学和生化标志物显示出前景。
本研究的目的是测试非经验丰富的读者在定量肠动力分析中的多读者一致性。
一项单中心回顾性研究纳入了所有18岁以下患有儿童炎症性肠病且在2012年至2022年间接受过不止一次MRE检查的患者。前两次MRE的电影图像使用定量动力软件进行处理。两名经验丰富的读者使用共识性sMaRIA(下降≥2分)提供反应的参考标准,并测量动力指数的变化(Δ)。两名资深读者和三名初级读者对每位患者的反应进行视觉评估,并记录Δ动力指数。对于每对读者,通过Bland-Altman偏差和Δ动力指数(任意单位,a.u.)的一致性界限以及Δ方向上的%一致性来评估读者间的一致性。
Δ方向上的百分比一致性为中等至优秀。初级读者与经验丰富读者的一致性为73-84%,资深读者与经验丰富读者的一致性为67-85%。Δ动力指数的Bland-Altman图显示无系统偏差,初级-经验丰富读者的一致性界限可接受。
不同经验的读者对儿童炎症性肠病进行定量肠动力分析时,一致性良好。