Addeh Abdoljalil, Williams Rebecca J, Golestani Ali, Pike G Bruce, MacDonald M Ethan
Department of Biomedical Engineering, Schulich School of Engineering, University of Calgary, Calgary, Alberta, Canada.
Department of Electrical & Software Engineering, Schulich School of Engineering, University of Calgary, Calgary, Alberta, Canada.
NMR Biomed. 2025 Jul;38(7):e70076. doi: 10.1002/nbm.70076.
Functional magnetic resonance imaging (fMRI) has opened new frontiers in neuroscience by instrumentally driving our understanding of brain function and development. Despite its substantial successes, fMRI studies persistently encounter obstacles stemming from inherent, unavoidable physiological confounds. The adverse effects of these confounds are especially noticeable with higher magnetic fields, which have been gaining momentum in fMRI experiments. This review focuses on the four major physiological confounds impacting fMRI studies: low-frequency fluctuations in both breathing depth and rate, low-frequency fluctuations in the heart rate, thoracic movements, and cardiac pulsatility. Over the past three decades, numerous correction techniques have emerged to address these challenges. Correction methods have effectively enhanced the detection of task-activated voxels and minimized the occurrence of false positives and false negatives in functional connectivity studies. While confound correction methods have merit, they also have certain limitations. For instance, model-based approaches require externally recorded physiological data that is often unavailable in fMRI studies. Methods reliant on independent component analysis, on the other hand, need prior knowledge about the number of components. Machine learning techniques, although showing potential, are still in the early stages of development and require additional validation. This article reviews the mechanics of physiological confound correction methods, scrutinizes their performance and limitations, and discusses their impact on fMRI studies.
功能磁共振成像(fMRI)通过推动我们对大脑功能和发育的理解,在神经科学领域开辟了新的前沿。尽管取得了巨大成功,但fMRI研究一直面临着源于内在、不可避免的生理混杂因素的障碍。这些混杂因素的不利影响在更高磁场下尤为明显,而更高磁场在fMRI实验中越来越受到青睐。本综述重点关注影响fMRI研究的四大生理混杂因素:呼吸深度和频率的低频波动、心率的低频波动、胸部运动和心脏搏动。在过去三十年中,出现了许多校正技术来应对这些挑战。校正方法有效地增强了对任务激活体素的检测,并在功能连接性研究中最大限度地减少了假阳性和假阴性的出现。虽然混杂因素校正方法有其优点,但也有一定的局限性。例如,基于模型的方法需要外部记录的生理数据,而这些数据在fMRI研究中往往无法获得。另一方面,依赖独立成分分析的方法需要关于成分数量的先验知识。机器学习技术虽然显示出潜力,但仍处于发展初期,需要进一步验证。本文回顾了生理混杂因素校正方法的原理,审视了它们的性能和局限性,并讨论了它们对fMRI研究的影响。