Nabia Sarah, Betron Myra, Arlotti-Parish Elizabeth, Varnauskas Amanda, Nduka Chinelo Cynthia, Pius Angioha, Munro Jean, Bagshaw Katharine, Wonodi Chizoba Barbara
USAID's MOMENTUM Country and Global Leadership, International Vaccine Access Center (IVAC), Department of International Health, Bloomberg School of Public Health, Johns Hopkins University, Baltimore, MD, United States.
Department of International Health, Bloomberg School of Public Health, Johns Hopkins University, Baltimore, MD, United States.
Front Public Health. 2025 May 26;13:1539190. doi: 10.3389/fpubh.2025.1539190. eCollection 2025.
Despite widespread evidence and recognition that women bear the disproportionate burden of caregiving, there are major gaps in action geared towards equalizing this burden of care between men and women especially in the context of child health and immunization. The goal of this rapid review is to identify and summarize effective and promising strategies for men's engagement in child health and immunization in low-and-middle-income countries (LMICs) and further categorize the strategies into its potential for gender transformative outcomes.
We searched PubMed, Embase and CINAHL databases for peer-reviewed literature and identified grey literature sources through key informant interviews. Twenty-seven papers and/or documents were included in the analysis. Data analysis was done through narrative synthesis, and results have been presented using the various levels of the socio-ecological model (SEM).
Majority strategies were at the "intrapersonal" level of SEM and focused on individual education and awareness building through one-on-one or group communication approaches and practical training. Efficacy of these strategies was measured using various indicators such as knowledge and perception levels, paternal-infant attachment, biological marker levels, and paternal behavior. Joint / shared couples' decision-making was the only gender transformative outcome reported in this review.
We found gaps in community and policy level interventions, and provider-side interventions to positively influence men's engagement in child health and immunization. Moreover, only two studies measured the strategies' influence on improving immunization outcomes.
It can be concluded there is a significant need for more evidence on gender-transformative approaches in child health and immunization programming in LMICs.
尽管有广泛的证据表明且人们也认识到女性承担着不成比例的照护负担,但在采取行动以平衡男性和女性之间的这种照护负担方面仍存在重大差距,尤其是在儿童健康和免疫接种方面。本快速综述的目的是识别并总结中低收入国家男性参与儿童健康和免疫接种的有效且有前景的策略,并进一步将这些策略按其实现性别变革性成果的潜力进行分类。
我们在PubMed、Embase和CINAHL数据库中搜索同行评审文献,并通过关键信息人访谈确定灰色文献来源。27篇论文和/或文件被纳入分析。数据分析通过叙述性综合进行,结果已使用社会生态模型(SEM)的不同层次呈现。
大多数策略处于社会生态模型的“个人内部”层面,侧重于通过一对一或小组沟通方式以及实践培训进行个人教育和意识培养。这些策略的有效性通过各种指标来衡量,如知识水平和认知水平、父子依恋、生物标志物水平以及父亲行为。本综述中报告的唯一性别变革性成果是夫妻共同/共享决策。
我们发现社区和政策层面的干预措施以及提供者层面的干预措施存在差距,这些干预措施未能积极影响男性参与儿童健康和免疫接种。此外,只有两项研究衡量了这些策略对改善免疫接种结果的影响。
可以得出结论,在中低收入国家的儿童健康和免疫接种规划中,迫切需要更多关于性别变革性方法的证据。