Vu Sharon, Reese Logan, Patel Neha, Hung Man
Boston University Graduate Medical Science Boston Massachusetts USA.
Roseman University of Health Sciences College of Dental Medicine South Jordan Utah USA.
Public Health Chall. 2024 Jul 17;3(3):e219. doi: 10.1002/puh2.219. eCollection 2024 Sep.
Assessing patient satisfaction is an effective way to provide an evaluation of the quality of healthcare services. As a result, the Hospital Consumer Assessment of Healthcare Providers and Systems (HCAHPS) Patient Survey was established as the first standardized national survey to publicly report patient ratings on hospital care. There remains a lack of research that examines rural-urban distinctions in patient satisfaction. The objective of this study was to investigate if there is a difference in hospital determinants of patient satisfaction among hospitals based on rural status.
The study utilized two public datasets containing HCAHPS survey results from 4714 US hospitals and from eligible cancer hospitals that participate in the Prospective Payment System-Exempt Cancer Hospital Quality Reporting. The data were collected from July 1, 2021 to June 30, 2022 and published by Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services. Rural status of each hospital was determined by matching zip codes with data provided by the Health Resources & Services Administration.
A total of 3248 hospitals were included in the analysis, with approximately 51.14% located in rural areas. There was a significant difference across every hospital determinant when comparing rural and non-rural status. Rural hospitals had a higher score for every hospital determinant (Cleanliness, Nurse communication, Doctor communication, Staff responsiveness, Communication about medicines, Discharge information, Care transition, Overall hospital rating, Quietness, and Willingness to recommend the hospital), indicating better performance.
Rural hospitals demonstrated better HCAHPS performance across every hospital determinant in comparison to urban hospitals, suggesting possible recent improvements. Future research is necessary to investigate this trend and its consistency, which can inform targeted interventions to better address the healthcare needs of diverse populations in the United States.
评估患者满意度是评价医疗服务质量的有效方式。因此,医院患者对医疗服务提供者及系统的评估(HCAHPS)患者调查被确立为首个公开报告患者对医院护理评分的全国标准化调查。目前仍缺乏对患者满意度城乡差异的研究。本研究的目的是调查基于农村状况的医院中,患者满意度的医院决定因素是否存在差异。
本研究使用了两个公共数据集,其中包含来自4714家美国医院以及参与前瞻性支付系统豁免癌症医院质量报告的合格癌症医院的HCAHPS调查结果。数据收集时间为2021年7月1日至2022年6月30日,由医疗保险和医疗补助服务中心发布。每家医院的农村状况通过将邮政编码与卫生资源和服务管理局提供的数据进行匹配来确定。
共有3248家医院纳入分析,其中约51.14%位于农村地区。在比较农村和非农村状况时,每个医院决定因素都存在显著差异。农村医院在每个医院决定因素(清洁度、护士沟通、医生沟通、工作人员响应能力、用药沟通、出院信息、护理过渡、医院总体评分、安静程度以及推荐医院的意愿)上得分更高,表明表现更好。
与城市医院相比,农村医院在每个医院决定因素上的HCAHPS表现更好,这表明近期可能有所改善。有必要进行进一步研究以调查这一趋势及其一致性,从而为有针对性的干预措施提供依据,以更好地满足美国不同人群的医疗需求。