Grace Sara
Lecturer in Criminology, University of Salford, Salford, UK.
Policing (Oxf). 2020 Jul 12:paaa029. doi: 10.1093/police/paaa029.
Drawing on motivational posturing theory (MPT) and procedural justice theory (PJT), this article makes recommendations for how best to secure compliance with social distancing regulations. Applying those theories to-mostly observational-data from a study on the use and impact of penalty notices for disorder, the influences on cooperation during police-citizen encounters are explored. Whilst focusing on the English data/regulations, as both MPT and PJT have been tested internationally, the conclusions have relevance beyond these shores. The article proposes a sixth posture-compulsion, a form of resistant compliance-to the five set out by MPT. Focusing attention not just on whether compliance is achieved but how recognizes the risk to future legitimacy posed by only achieving compliance through coercion or the threat thereof. Lessons from the research are applied to policing social distancing, with regards to: securing compliance during interactions, self-regulation and enforcement action, and how to preserve police legitimacy.
本文借鉴动机姿态理论(MPT)和程序正义理论(PJT),就如何最好地确保人们遵守社交距离规定提出建议。将这些理论应用于一项关于扰乱秩序罚单的使用和影响的研究中的大部分观察数据,探讨警察与公民互动过程中对合作的影响。虽然重点关注英国的数据/规定,但由于MPT和PJT都已在国际上得到验证,因此得出的结论在英国以外地区也具有相关性。本文提出了一种第六种姿态——强制,这是一种抵抗性的服从形式,补充了MPT提出的五种姿态。不仅关注是否实现了服从,还关注如何实现服从,认识到仅通过强制或威胁来实现服从对未来合法性构成的风险。研究所得经验教训被应用于维持社交距离的治安工作,涉及以下方面:在互动过程中确保服从、自我监管和执法行动,以及如何维护警察的合法性。