Roos L L, Cageorge S M, Austen E, Lohr K N
Am J Public Health. 1985 Nov;75(11):1288-95. doi: 10.2105/ajph.75.11.1288.
We used the Health Services Commission data from Manitoba, Canada to identify complications resulting from hysterectomy, cholecystectomy, and prostatectomy which led to hospital readmissions. For each procedure, two specialists independently judged whether the readmissions were for surgery-related complications on the basis of liberally interpreted literature guidelines. Then, each pair of physicians met to resolve differences; only complications agreed upon by physicians were retained in our computer-based analysis. The analysis was done in three steps: algorithms were developed using guidelines from the literature, physician input, and 1974 hospital claims; these were then modified using 1975 data; finally, the algorithms were tested with 1976 data. The computerized algorithms developed were compared with the clinical decisions of physician panels. The results showed high specificity, sensitivity, and predictive value. Given the increasing availability of routinely collected data bases, the possibilities for inexpensively monitoring the outcomes of different providers and institutions are appealing. More extensive validation and application of the methodology to a greater number of procedures are necessary to implement such a program.
我们使用了来自加拿大曼尼托巴省卫生服务委员会的数据,以确定子宫切除术、胆囊切除术和前列腺切除术导致再次入院的并发症。对于每一种手术,两名专家根据宽泛解释的文献指南,独立判断再次入院是否是由手术相关并发症引起的。然后,每对医生会面以解决分歧;只有医生们一致认可的并发症才会被纳入我们基于计算机的分析中。分析分三个步骤进行:利用文献指南、医生的意见以及1974年的医院索赔数据开发算法;然后使用1975年的数据对这些算法进行修改;最后,用1976年的数据对算法进行测试。将开发出的计算机化算法与医生小组的临床决策进行比较。结果显示出高特异性、敏感性和预测价值。鉴于常规收集的数据库越来越容易获取,以低成本监测不同医疗服务提供者和机构的治疗结果具有吸引力。要实施这样一个项目,有必要对该方法进行更广泛的验证,并将其应用于更多的手术。