Smędra Anna, Wochna Katarzyna, Kubiak Rafał, Berent Jarosław
Department of Forensic Medicine, Medical University of Lodz, Poland.
Department of Criminal Law, University of Lodz, Poland.
Anaesthesiol Intensive Ther. 2025 Jun 4;57(1):108-114. doi: 10.5114/ait/203166.
The healthcare system is one of the areas most affected by the COVID-19 pandemic in Poland. This resulted in a higher occurrence of medical errors at diffe-rent stages of diagnosis and patient treatment. This study aimed to determine how the COVID-19 pandemic affected the number and type of medical errors in Poland and the type of medical facility where the irregularity occurred.
We reviewed inquiries into the correctness of medical proceedings related to COVID-19; these were received by our department from prosecutor's offices throughout Poland during the pandemic and after its end: from the beginning of January 2020 to the end of December 2023. During the examined period (48 months), the department received a total of 4,483 inquiries, i.e. approximately 4.5 per day (approximately 1,000 working days). Of these, 293 were related to the COVID-19 pandemic (6.54%) and were further analyzed according to the selected criteria. Inquiries regarding "COVID" cases concerned all aspects of medical procedures, all medical professions, and all healthcare entities.
A clear correlation was found: most inquiries raising doubts about the correctness of medical procedures were received during the peaks (waves) of the pandemic: autumn 2020, spring 2021, late autumn 2021, and winter 2021/2022.
Despite the introduction of legal regulations intended to decriminalize consequences of medical errors related to the COVID-19 pandemic, such cases were still submitted to prosecutors' offices; prosecutors initiated proceedings and then commissioned expert opinions on the correctness of the medical procedure.
医疗系统是波兰受新冠疫情影响最严重的领域之一。这导致在诊断和患者治疗的不同阶段出现医疗错误的情况增多。本研究旨在确定新冠疫情如何影响波兰医疗错误的数量和类型,以及出现违规行为的医疗机构类型。
我们审查了与新冠疫情相关医疗程序正确性的问询;这些问询在疫情期间及结束后由我们部门从波兰各地的检察官办公室收到:从2020年1月初至2023年12月底。在审查期间(48个月),该部门共收到4483份问询,即每天约4.5份(约1000个工作日)。其中,293份与新冠疫情相关(6.54%),并根据选定标准进行了进一步分析。关于“新冠”病例的问询涉及医疗程序的各个方面、所有医疗专业和所有医疗保健实体。
发现了明显的相关性:对医疗程序正确性提出质疑的大多数问询是在疫情高峰期(波峰)收到的:2020年秋季、2021年春季、2021年深秋和2021/2022年冬季。
尽管出台了旨在将与新冠疫情相关医疗错误后果非刑事化的法律法规,但此类案件仍被提交至检察官办公室;检察官启动了程序,然后委托专家对医疗程序的正确性发表意见。