Gilworth Rachel E, Skinner Bethany D, Hodgkiss Daniel D, Lucas Samuel J E, Lucas Rebekah A I
School of Sport, Exercise and Rehabilitation Sciences, University of Birmingham, Birmingham, United Kingdom.
Front Physiol. 2025 Jun 3;16:1507398. doi: 10.3389/fphys.2025.1507398. eCollection 2025.
Increasing numbers of females are performing in increasingly hot environments. This scoping review aimed to 1) collate evidence on the effects of environmental heat stress on aerobic exercise performance and work productivity in females specifically, and 2) explore sex differences in the existing literature. A systematic search across four databases (PubMed, MEDLINE, Web of Science and SPORTDiscus) was developed based on MeSH terms and keywords, with all permutations relating to 'FEMALE', 'WOMAN', 'HEAT' AND 'PERFORMANCE'. Identified articles were screened against pre-defined inclusion criteria related to age (16-60 years), environmental heat stress (≥23°C), and physical activity duration (≥5 min). We identified 35,696 articles, of which 41 met the inclusion criteria. Of the included studies, 19 reported female-specific comparisons, two of which also investigated sex differences. Four studies investigated sex differences alone, while 18 studies included females within the participant cohort. Thirty-eight of the included studies assessed athletic performance and three studies examined occupational performance (i.e., work output/productivity) in females. Existing data on the effect of heat stress on performance was predominantly from pre-menopausal cohorts (mean age 29 years, range 20-46 years), with no studies investigating peri- or post-menopausal cohorts. We uncovered limited research investigating the effect of menstrual cycle phase (six studies) or hormonal contraceptive use (two studies) on performance in the heat. Thirteen included studies examined interventions pre or during performance test(s), with four studies showing their interventions attenuated heat stress performance impairments in female cohorts. We highlight notable gaps in the literature regarding female performance in the heat; specifically, the influence of peri-post menopause, heat stress interventions for females, and impacts on females in the occupational sector. We recommend that researchers undertaking exercise and thermal physiological research aim for gender balance where possible and adhere to guidelines when designing and reporting research that encompasses females. Addressing these research gaps would provide workers, athletes, and practitioners with a better understanding of how to protect females and enhance their physical performance in the heat, across different stages of life, amidst a changing climate.
越来越多的女性在越来越炎热的环境中进行活动。本综述旨在:1)整理关于环境热应激对女性有氧运动表现和工作效率影响的证据;2)探索现有文献中的性别差异。基于医学主题词和关键词,在四个数据库(PubMed、MEDLINE、Web of Science和SPORTDiscus)中进行了系统检索,涉及与“女性”“妇女”“热”和“表现”相关的所有排列组合。根据预先定义的纳入标准(年龄16 - 60岁、环境热应激≥23°C、身体活动持续时间≥5分钟)对检索到的文章进行筛选。我们共识别出35,696篇文章,其中41篇符合纳入标准。在纳入的研究中,19项报告了特定于女性的比较,其中两项还研究了性别差异。四项研究单独研究了性别差异,18项研究在参与者队列中纳入了女性。纳入研究中的38项评估了运动表现,三项研究考察了女性的职业表现(即工作产出/生产力)。关于热应激对表现影响的现有数据主要来自绝经前队列(平均年龄29岁,范围20 - 46岁),没有研究调查绝经前后队列。我们发现研究月经周期阶段(六项研究)或激素避孕药使用(两项研究)对热环境中表现影响的研究有限。13项纳入研究在表现测试前或测试期间检查了干预措施,四项研究表明其干预措施减轻了女性队列中的热应激表现损伤。我们强调了文献中关于女性在热环境中表现的显著差距;具体而言,绝经前后的影响、针对女性的热应激干预措施以及对职业领域女性的影响。我们建议从事运动和热生理研究的人员尽可能实现性别平衡,并在设计和报告包含女性的研究时遵循指南。填补这些研究空白将使工人、运动员和从业者更好地理解如何在气候变化的背景下,在生命的不同阶段保护女性并提高她们在热环境中的身体表现。