Bauler Sarah, Tse Carmen, Dos Santos Aicha, Moises Lucilia, Mbouemboue Nicole, Young Melissa, Gittelsohn Joel, George Christine Marie, Leontsini Elli
World Vision International, London, UK.
World Vision Mozambique, Monapo, Mozambique.
Trop Med Health. 2025 Jun 18;53(1):85. doi: 10.1186/s41182-025-00768-8.
Globally, iron-deficiency anemia is the most common micronutrient deficiency and a leading cause of disability-adjusted life years lost among adolescent girls 10-19 years of age. Adolescent girls' voices are often excluded from shaping the interventions and policies designed to support them. We used participatory formative research methods-photovoice and adolescent-centered design (ACD)-to explore nutrition-related challenges, opportunities, and preferences among adolescent girls in Monapo District, Mozambique, and used the findings to contextualize a nutrition curriculum and supplement delivery platform.
We purposively selected 16 girls from three rural and peri-rural secondary schools divided equally into two age groups (13-16 years and 17-20 years) and asked them to take photos of their food environment. Following a week of photo-taking, participants discussed their photos using the SHOWeD methodology in two workshops and in follow-up individual interviews. We also conducted three ACD group discussions with girls 13 to 20 years, each consisting of 10 to 12 participants, to explore consumption and supplement packaging preferences.
Thematic analysis of photos and transcripts showed that participants preferred locally grown foods and indigenous protein sources and were actively engaged in agriculture and household chores, highlighting opportunities for nutritional improvement. However, their nutrition was constrained by seasonal food shortages, inequitable household responsibilities compared to boys, and limited social capital. While school-based supplementation is the standard practice, participants strongly preferred to take supplements at home to avoid stigma and benefit from the comfort and privacy of their own homes. We used these insights to refine the adolescent nutrition curriculum and design a multiple micronutrient supplementation delivery platform.
Photovoice provided rich visual data about the lived experiences of adolescent girls in a fragile and resource-constrained context, without the influence of an external researcher interpreting everyday realities, and elicited valuable insights into the barriers, opportunities, and potential improvements in nutrition programming. Integrating photovoice and ACD into program design can increase program acceptability and potential for effectiveness. This research also highlights the need to prioritize adolescent engagement and underscores the inadequacy of one-size-fits-all approaches, such as school-based supplementation programs.
在全球范围内,缺铁性贫血是最常见的微量营养素缺乏症,也是10至19岁少女中伤残调整生命年损失的主要原因。在制定旨在支持少女的干预措施和政策时,往往没有听取她们的意见。我们采用参与式形成性研究方法——照片声音法和以青少年为中心的设计(ACD),来探索莫桑比克莫纳波区少女在营养方面面临的挑战、机遇和偏好,并利用研究结果来制定适合当地情况的营养课程和补充剂发放平台。
我们从三所农村和城郊中学中有意挑选了16名女孩,平均分为两个年龄组(13至16岁和17至20岁),并要求她们拍摄自己食物环境的照片。在为期一周的拍摄之后,参与者在两个工作坊以及后续的个人访谈中,使用SHOWeD方法讨论了她们的照片。我们还与13至20岁的女孩进行了三次ACD小组讨论,每次讨论由10至12名参与者组成,以探讨她们对食物消费和补充剂包装的偏好。
对照片和文字记录的主题分析表明,参与者更喜欢当地种植的食物和本土蛋白质来源,并且积极参与农业和家务劳动,这凸显了改善营养状况的机会。然而,她们的营养状况受到季节性食物短缺、与男孩相比不平等的家务负担以及有限的社会资本的限制。虽然以学校为基础的补充剂发放是标准做法,但参与者强烈倾向于在家中服用补充剂,以避免耻辱感,并能在自己家中享受舒适和私密的环境。我们利用这些见解完善了青少年营养课程,并设计了一个多种微量营养素补充剂发放平台。
照片声音法提供了关于处于脆弱和资源受限环境中的少女生活经历的丰富视觉数据,不受外部研究人员对日常现实的解读的影响,并引发了对营养规划中的障碍、机遇和潜在改进的宝贵见解。将照片声音法和ACD整合到项目设计中,可以提高项目的可接受性和有效性潜力。这项研究还强调了优先让青少年参与的必要性,并凸显了一刀切方法(如以学校为基础的补充剂项目)的不足之处。