Shalom Jonathan G, Prihar Adi, Strauss Asher Y, Huppert Jonathan D, Andersson Gerhard, Aderka Idan M
School of Psychological Sciences University of Haifa.
The Hebrew University of Jerusalem.
Behav Ther. 2025 Jul;56(4):812-822. doi: 10.1016/j.beth.2025.01.002. Epub 2025 Jan 13.
The therapeutic alliance is a consistent predictor of treatment outcome. In the present study, we examined whether the therapeutic alliance is associated with symptoms of social anxiety along the course of internet-delivered cognitive behavior therapy (ICBT) for social anxiety disorder (SAD). We examined data from a large treatment trial (n = 182) in which individuals with SAD reported on their social anxiety and alliance with the therapist each week during the treatment (for 11 weeks). We examined the total variance in alliance as well as within- and between-individual variances separately. Consistent with our hypotheses, we found that the total variance in alliance predicted the total variance in social anxiety in the following week. In addition, we found that within-individual variance in alliance was negatively associated with within-individual variance in social anxiety (in the following week). Thus, weekly increases in alliances were associated with weekly reductions in social anxiety in the following week. Finally, we found that between-individual variance in alliance was positively associated with between-individual variance in social anxiety such that individuals who were more socially anxious created stronger alliances with their therapists over the course of treatment. Our findings suggest that the therapeutic alliance is important in ICBT for SAD, that separating variance into within and between components may help identify different psychological processes, and that improving within-individual alliance may lead to reductions in symptoms of social anxiety.
治疗联盟是治疗结果的一个持续预测指标。在本研究中,我们考察了在针对社交焦虑障碍(SAD)的互联网认知行为疗法(ICBT)过程中,治疗联盟是否与社交焦虑症状相关。我们分析了一项大型治疗试验(n = 182)的数据,在该试验中,患有SAD的个体在治疗期间(为期11周)每周报告他们的社交焦虑情况以及与治疗师的联盟情况。我们分别考察了联盟的总方差以及个体内方差和个体间方差。与我们的假设一致,我们发现联盟的总方差预测了下一周社交焦虑的总方差。此外,我们发现联盟的个体内方差与社交焦虑的个体内方差(下一周)呈负相关。因此,联盟每周的增加与下一周社交焦虑的每周减少相关。最后,我们发现联盟的个体间方差与社交焦虑的个体间方差呈正相关,即社交焦虑程度较高的个体在治疗过程中与治疗师建立了更强的联盟。我们的研究结果表明,治疗联盟在针对SAD的ICBT中很重要,将方差分为个体内和个体间成分可能有助于识别不同的心理过程,并且改善个体内联盟可能会导致社交焦虑症状的减轻。