Makieh Muhammad Oweis, Lababidi Muhammad Ibrahim, Makieh Ramah Eimad, Abdul-Hak Mahmoud
Damascus University, Damascus, Syria.
Pediatric Dentistry, Damascus University, Damascus, Syria.
BDJ Open. 2025 Jun 20;11(1):60. doi: 10.1038/s41405-025-00341-9.
This study investigates refusal rates of dentists in Damascus, Syria, to manage patients who disclose that they are carriers of tuberculosis, human immunodeficiency virus (HIV), hepatitis B and C (HBV/HCV), and patients with dental phobia, asthma, epilepsy, patients unable to afford dental care, and children. The aims are to identify to what extent dentists refuse patients who are diagnosed carriers of certain blood born viruses, require extra measures, take a lot of time, or do not pay.
A cross-sectional study was conducted in Damascus by distributing paper and electronic questionnaires to dental clinics based on the administrative divisions of the city.
A total of 246 responses were collected. The average years of dental practice among respondents was 9.39 ± 9.8. Rates of refusal were as follows: children (n = 55, 22.4%), tuberculosis (n = 176, 71.5%), HIV (n = 192, 78.0%), HBV/HCV (n = 98, 39.8%), dental phobia (n = 58, 23.6%), asthma (n = 12, 4.9%), and epilepsy (n = 73, 29.7%). Acceptance of patients with tuberculosis, HIV, and HBV/HCV was positively associated with greater years of experience. Dentists who graduated outside of Syria were more likely to accept treating patients with HIV and HBV/HCV. A significant correlation was found between refusal rates for patients with tuberculosis, HIV and HBV/HCV.
The proportion of dentists in Damascus refusing to treat patients who disclose that they are carriers of tuberculosis, HIV/AIDS, and HBV/HCV was notably high. Managing patients who cannot afford treatment often involved reducing fees. The findings provide valuable insights into the systemic challenges in healthcare delivery and propose possible improvements in managing vulnerable population in resource-constrained settings.
本研究调查了叙利亚大马士革的牙医拒绝诊治以下几类患者的比例:那些透露自己是结核病、人类免疫缺陷病毒(HIV)、乙型和丙型肝炎(HBV/HCV)携带者的患者,以及患有牙科恐惧症、哮喘、癫痫的患者,无力承担牙科护理费用的患者和儿童。目的是确定牙医在多大程度上拒绝诊断为某些血源病毒携带者、需要额外措施、耗时较长或不付费的患者。
在大马士革进行了一项横断面研究,根据城市行政区向牙科诊所分发纸质问卷和电子问卷。
共收集到246份回复。受访者的平均牙科执业年限为9.39±9.8年。拒绝率如下:儿童(n = 55,22.4%)、结核病(n = 176,71.5%)、HIV(n = 192,78.0%)、HBV/HCV(n = 98,39.8%)、牙科恐惧症(n = 58,23.6%)、哮喘(n = 12,4.9%)和癫痫(n = 73,29.7%)。接受结核病、HIV和HBV/HCV患者与更多年的经验呈正相关。在叙利亚境外毕业的牙医更有可能接受治疗HIV和HBV/HCV患者。发现结核病、HIV和HBV/HCV患者的拒绝率之间存在显著相关性。
大马士革拒绝治疗那些透露自己是结核病、HIV/AIDS和HBV/HCV携带者的患者的牙医比例显著较高。管理无力承担治疗费用的患者通常涉及降低费用。这些发现为医疗服务提供中的系统性挑战提供了有价值的见解,并提出了在资源有限环境中管理弱势群体的可能改进措施。