Gab Allah Eman A, Shahein Mohamed M, Abuarab Mohamed E, Shaker Vector, Abdeldaym Emad A
Department of Vegetable, Faculty of Agriculture, Cairo University, Giza, 12613, Egypt.
Agricultural Engineering Department, Faculty of Agriculture, Cairo University, Giza, 12613, Egypt.
Sci Rep. 2025 Jun 20;15(1):20152. doi: 10.1038/s41598-025-05242-3.
Cocopeat is among the most frequently utilized substrates in soilless farming. Nonetheless, the extraction of Cocopeat generates a detrimental carbon footprint, highlighting the necessity for alternative, sustainable substrate options. To tackle this issue, we examined the effects of substituting Cocopeat with a blend of various Rice straw, Sawdust, and compost on cucumber growth and yield over two growing seasons, 2021-2022 and 2022-2023. The treatments included Cocopeat 100% (control), sawdust 100%, rice straw 100%, compost 100%, combinations of Cocopeat and sawdust (1:1, v/v), combinations of Cocopeat and sawdust (3:1, v/v), combinations of Cocopeat and rice straw (1:1, v/v), combinations of Cocopeat and rice straw (3:1, v/v), combinations of Cocopeat and compost (1:1, v/v), and combinations of Cocopeat and compost (3:1, v/v). The highest yield was recorded with rice straw at 100.55 ton ha, followed by the Coco 50%: Compost 50% treatment yielding 74.32 ton ha-1 and 69.26 ton ha, respectively, while the lowest yield was noted for sawdust at 22.23 ton ha. Across both growth seasons, rice straw achieved the highest irrigation water productivity (IWP) of 51.56 and 51.91 kg m, respectively, followed by Coco 50%: Rice straw 50% at 38.08 and 38.37 kg m, whereas sawdust resulted in the lowest IWPs of 6.93 and 11.48 kg m. In both growing seasons, the rice straw showed the greatest rate of photosynthesis, with readings of 23.34 µmol m s and 22.14 µmol m s, respectively. Conversely, the lowest photosynthesis rates during both growing seasons were observed with the Coco 75%: Compost 25% treatment, at 3.23 µmol m s and 3.03 µmol m s, respectively. The treated rice straw substrate media ranked as the most profitable and resilient option in terms of net present value (NPV) and benefit-cost (B/C) ratio metrics, followed closely by the compost treatment. It seems that treated rice straw-based media is a promising substrate in soilless culture systems as a viable alternative substrate for cucumber cultivation instead of Cocopeat substrate.
椰糠是无土栽培中最常用的基质之一。然而,椰糠的提取会产生有害的碳足迹,这凸显了寻找替代的、可持续基质选项的必要性。为了解决这个问题,我们在2021 - 2022年和2022 - 2023年两个生长季节研究了用各种稻草、锯末和堆肥的混合物替代椰糠对黄瓜生长和产量的影响。处理包括100%椰糠(对照)、100%锯末、100%稻草、100%堆肥、椰糠和锯末的组合(1:1, v/v)、椰糠和锯末的组合(3:1, v/v)、椰糠和稻草的组合(1:1, v/v)、椰糠和稻草的组合(3:1, v/v)、椰糠和堆肥的组合(1:1, v/v)以及椰糠和堆肥的组合(3:1, v/v)。稻草的产量最高,为100.55吨/公顷,其次是椰糠50%:堆肥50%处理,分别产量为74.32吨/公顷和69.26吨/公顷;而锯末的产量最低,为22.23吨/公顷。在两个生长季节中,稻草的灌溉水生产率(IWP)最高,分别为51.56和51.91千克/立方米,其次是椰糠50%:稻草50%处理,为38.08和38.37千克/立方米;而锯末的IWP最低,为6.93和11.48千克/立方米。在两个生长季节中,稻草的光合作用速率最高,分别为23.34微摩尔/平方米·秒和22.14微摩尔/平方米·秒。相反,在两个生长季节中,椰糠75%:堆肥25%处理的光合作用速率最低,分别为3.23微摩尔/平方米·秒和3.03微摩尔/平方米·秒。就净现值(NPV)和效益成本(B/C)比指标而言,处理过的稻草基质介质是最具盈利性和弹性的选择,堆肥处理紧随其后。看来,以处理过的稻草为基础的介质在无土栽培系统中是一种有前景的基质,可作为黄瓜栽培替代椰糠基质的可行选择。