Elbagory Mohssen, Zayed Amal, El-Khateeb Nagwa, El-Nahrawy Sahar, Omara Alaa El-Dein, Mohamed Ibrahim, Elbyaly Marwa Yasien Helmy, El-Sharkawy Mahmoud, Singh Jogendra, Dzaja Ana, Mioč Boro, Širić Ivan
Health Specialties, Basic Sciences and Applications Unit, Applied College, King Khalid University, Mohayil Asir Abha 61421, Saudi Arabia.
Educational Psychology Department, Faculty of Education, Kafrelsheikh University, Kafr El-Sheikh 33516, Egypt.
Toxics. 2025 Jun 13;13(6):497. doi: 10.3390/toxics13060497.
Unregulated irrigation with partially industrial effluents may lead to heavy metal contamination in crops and pose significant human health risks, especially in developing countries like India. Therefore, the present study aimed to quantify six heavy metals (Cd, Cr, Cu, Fe, Mn, and Zn) in soil and wheat irrigated with paper mill effluent, assess plant responses, and evaluate associated health risks for consumers. For this, a field study was conducted across ten sites (five effluent-irrigated, five borewell-irrigated as control), analyzing soil and wheat tissues for metal concentrations and calculating risk indices including bioaccumulation factor (Bf), translocation factor (Tf), Dietary Intake of Metals (DIM < 1), Health Risk Index (HRI < 1), and Target Hazard Quotient (THQ < 1). Results indicated high concentrations of Cd and Cr in effluent-irrigated soils and wheat tissues (root > stem > leaves > grains) compared to control sites, with some values exceeding permissible limits. Although the THQ values for heavy metals were below 1, indicating a low immediate health risk, concentrations of Cd and Cr in both soil and crop tissues exceeded acceptable safety standards. This study provides empirical evidence supporting the need for effluent treatment and policy interventions to mitigate agricultural contamination from the use of industrial effluents and protect public health.
使用部分工业废水进行无节制灌溉可能会导致农作物受到重金属污染,并对人类健康构成重大风险,尤其是在印度这样的发展中国家。因此,本研究旨在量化用造纸厂废水灌溉的土壤和小麦中的六种重金属(镉、铬、铜、铁、锰和锌),评估植物的反应,并评估消费者面临的相关健康风险。为此,在十个地点(五个用废水灌溉,五个用钻孔井水灌溉作为对照)开展了一项实地研究,分析土壤和小麦组织中的金属浓度,并计算风险指数,包括生物累积因子(Bf)、转运因子(Tf)、金属膳食摄入量(DIM < 1)、健康风险指数(HRI < 1)和目标危害商数(THQ < 1)。结果表明,与对照地点相比,用废水灌溉的土壤和小麦组织(根>茎>叶>籽粒)中镉和铬的浓度较高,有些值超过了允许限值。虽然重金属的THQ值低于1,表明当前健康风险较低,但土壤和作物组织中的镉和铬浓度均超过了可接受的安全标准。本研究提供了实证证据,支持需要进行废水处理和政策干预,以减轻工业废水使用造成的农业污染并保护公众健康。