Tuohy Pat, Heslop Neil, Mustard Jill, Bird Phil, Teagle Holly, Gunn Robert
Chair, Pindrop Foundation, Nelson, Aotearoa New Zealand.
CEO, Southern Cochlear Implant Programme, Christchurch, Aotearoa New Zealand.
N Z Med J. 2025 Jun 27;138(1617):50-61. doi: 10.26635/6965.6807.
We examined equity in the provision of cochlear implant services for New Zealand Māori compared with other New Zealanders.
The client databases of both Aotearoa New Zealand cochlear implant programmes were searched and an anonymised dataset was provided to the audit team. Ethics committee approval was not required. Ethnicity was categorised as Māori or non-Māori.
There is no significant difference between Māori and non-Māori with respect to acceptance for surgery rates and time from acceptance to surgery. Māori children and adults have a higher rate of proceeding to surgery than non-Māori ethnic groups. Average days to surgery for adult clients reduced over the period studied. Time to surgery was low for both child ethnic groups. When a measure of prioritisation (clinical priority access criteria [CPAC]) was incorporated into the evaluation, we found that Māori clients waited slightly, but not significantly less time per unit of CPAC scored.
We were able to demonstrate that once Māori clients accessed the cochlear implant programmes, they were implanted at a similar rate as non-Māori, and adult clients experienced equivalent waiting times even when adjusted for CPAC score. These favourable results suggest that our internal systems and pathways are promoting equity.
我们研究了与其他新西兰人相比,新西兰毛利人接受人工耳蜗植入服务的公平性。
检索了新西兰人工耳蜗植入项目的客户数据库,并向审计团队提供了一个匿名数据集。无需伦理委员会批准。种族分为毛利人和非毛利人。
毛利人和非毛利人在手术接受率以及从接受手术到实际手术的时间方面没有显著差异。毛利儿童和成人进行手术的比率高于非毛利族群。在研究期间,成年客户的平均手术天数减少。两个儿童族群的手术时间都较短。当将一种优先排序措施(临床优先准入标准[CPAC])纳入评估时,我们发现毛利客户每获得一个CPAC分数的等待时间略短,但差异不显著。
我们能够证明,一旦毛利客户进入人工耳蜗植入项目,他们的植入率与非毛利人相似,即使根据CPAC分数进行调整,成年客户的等待时间也相当。这些良好结果表明我们的内部系统和流程正在促进公平性。