Roze des Ordons Amanda, Kassam Aliya, Ellaway Rachel
Department of Critical Care Medicine; Department of Anesthesiology; Division of Palliative Medicine, Department of Oncology, Cumming School of Medicine, University of Calgary, Calgary, Alberta, Canada.
Department of Community Health Sciences, Cumming School of Medicine, University of Calgary, Alberta, Canada.
Med Educ. 2025 Sep;59(9):983-995. doi: 10.1111/medu.15747. Epub 2025 Jun 26.
Resident physicians may experience psychological trauma both at work and in their personal lives. Injury from trauma can impact learning, patient care, relationships, mental health and well-being. Residents' experiences of traumatic injury have not been well-described in the literature. The purpose of this study was to explore residents' lived experiences of psychological traumatic injury.
The research employed a hermeneutic phenomenological methodology. All residents at a single Canadian medical school and support professionals who work with them were invited to participate in semi-structured interviews. Anonymized transcripts were analysed in duplicate and findings interpreted through discussion amongst the research team.
Thirteen residents and three support professionals participated. Four core domains of lived experience within participant narratives were identified, each with multiple dimensions: impacts of traumatic injury (multifaceted, internal reactions, layered judgements), adaptations to traumatic injury (shifts in mindset and behaviour), traumatic injury over time (acknowledging, oscillation, meaning-making) and modifiers of traumatic injury (previous life experiences, internal resources, contextual circumstances). Three metanarratives intersecting these dimensions of experience were complexity, sociocultural influences and existential tensions.
In summary, residents' experiences of trauma and the associated traumatic injury are complex, highly individual and difficult to anticipate or resolve with linear support models. This research will help guide ways to better support residents while addressing problematic aspects of medical education that may contribute to experiences of trauma.
住院医师在工作和个人生活中都可能经历心理创伤。创伤造成的伤害会影响学习、患者护理、人际关系、心理健康和幸福感。住院医师遭受创伤性伤害的经历在文献中尚未得到充分描述。本研究的目的是探索住院医师心理创伤性伤害的生活经历。
本研究采用诠释现象学方法。邀请了一所加拿大医学院的所有住院医师以及与他们共事的支持人员参与半结构化访谈。对匿名的访谈记录进行了双人分析,并通过研究团队的讨论对研究结果进行了解释。
13名住院医师和3名支持人员参与了研究。在参与者的叙述中确定了四个生活经历的核心领域,每个领域都有多个维度:创伤性伤害的影响(多方面的、内在反应、分层判断)、对创伤性伤害的适应(思维模式和行为的转变)、创伤性伤害随时间的变化(认知、波动、意义建构)以及创伤性伤害的调节因素(以前的生活经历、内在资源、背景情况)。与这些经历维度相交的三个元叙事是复杂性、社会文化影响和生存张力。
总之,住院医师的创伤经历和相关的创伤性伤害是复杂的、高度个体化的,很难用线性支持模型来预测或解决。这项研究将有助于指导如何更好地支持住院医师,同时解决医学教育中可能导致创伤经历的问题方面。