Mwangala Patrick Nzivo, Kerubo Anita, Makandi Millicent, Odhiambo Rachael, Abubakar Amina
Institute for Human Development, Aga Khan University, Nairobi, Kenya.
PLOS Glob Public Health. 2025 Jun 30;5(6):e0004130. doi: 10.1371/journal.pgph.0004130. eCollection 2025.
Data on the burden and determinants of mental and substance use problems among women in urban and rural informal settlements in Kenya is sparse, thus limiting preventive and treatment efforts in these areas. To bridge the gap, we (a) determined the prevalence of depressive, anxiety and post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD) symptoms and alcohol and drug use problems among women compared to their spouses and (b) examined the correlates of these outcomes. Data collection for this cross-sectional survey was conducted in 2022 in Mombasa, Kwale and Nairobi counties in Kenya. A total of 1528 adults (1048 women) took part. The 9-Item Patient Health Questionnaire, 7-Item Generalized Anxiety Disorder Scale, Primary Care PTSD Screen for DSM-5, Alcohol Use Disorders Identification Test, and Drug Use Disorders Identification Test were administered alongside other measures. Logistic regression was used to examine the correlates of mental and substance use problems. Overall, the prevalence of mental and substance use problems among women and men respectively was 28% (95% CI 25, 31%) vs 22% (95% CI 18, 26%) [depressive symptoms], 12% (95% CI 10, 14%) vs 8% (95% CI 6, 11%) [general anxiety symptoms], 22% (95% CI 19, 24%) vs 21% (95% CI 17, 25%) [PTSD symptoms], 4% (95% CI 3, 5%) vs 15% (95% CI 12, 19%) [alcohol use problems], and 2% (95% CI 1, 3%) vs 12% (95% CI 9, 15%) [drug use problems]. The prevalence of depressive and anxiety symptoms was significantly higher among women compared to their male counterparts. On the other hand, both current and past-year alcohol and drug use were significantly higher in men than women. Among women, stressful life events, urban residence, food insecurity, family debt, unemployment, poor self-rated health, poor eyesight, and higher educational level were the correlates for elevated depressive, anxiety and PTSD symptoms. Conversely, sexual abuse, living in rented houses, urban residence, verbal abuse, stressful life events, and somatic complaints were the correlates for depressive, anxiety and PTSD symptoms in men. Correlates against mental health problems included social support, higher subjective wellbeing, older age (>50 years), increased vigorous exercise and higher household income (in both sexes). Correlates for current alcohol use in women included stressful life events, urban residence, being sexually active, and living in a single family. Among men, higher household income was associated with current alcohol use. Correlates against current alcohol use included being married, living in a larger household (>5), being a Muslim and having multimorbidity (in both sexes). Correlates for current drug use included unemployment and sexual abuse. Female sex was associated with reduced odds of current drug use. The prevalence of depressive, anxiety and PTSD symptoms, and alcohol use problems is high in the study setting. However, needs vary by gender and study location, highlighting the importance of targeted approaches in mental health services. Our results also highlight the need for integrating mental health services into existing primary care as well as testing and scaling multi-component mental health interventions in this population.
关于肯尼亚城乡非正规住区女性心理和物质使用问题的负担及决定因素的数据稀少,这限制了这些地区的预防和治疗工作。为了填补这一空白,我们(a)确定了与配偶相比,女性中抑郁、焦虑和创伤后应激障碍(PTSD)症状以及酒精和药物使用问题的患病率,(b)并研究了这些结果的相关因素。这项横断面调查的数据收集于2022年在肯尼亚的蒙巴萨、夸莱和内罗毕县进行。共有1528名成年人(1048名女性)参与。同时还实施了9项患者健康问卷、7项广泛性焦虑障碍量表、DSM-5初级保健PTSD筛查、酒精使用障碍识别测试和药物使用障碍识别测试以及其他测量方法。采用逻辑回归分析来研究心理和物质使用问题的相关因素。总体而言,女性和男性中心理和物质使用问题的患病率分别为28%(95%置信区间25, 31%)对22%(95%置信区间18, 26%)[抑郁症状],12%(95%置信区间10, 14%)对8%(95%置信区间6, 11%)[广泛性焦虑症状],22%(95%置信区间19, 24%)对21%(95%置信区间17, 25%)[PTSD症状],4%(95%置信区间3, 5%)对15%(95%置信区间12, 19%)[酒精使用问题],以及2%(95%置信区间1, 3%)对12%(95%置信区间9, 15%)[药物使用问题]。与男性相比,女性中抑郁和焦虑症状的患病率显著更高。另一方面,男性当前和过去一年的酒精和药物使用均显著高于女性。在女性中,压力性生活事件、城市居住、粮食不安全、家庭债务、失业、自评健康状况差、视力差和较高的教育水平是抑郁、焦虑和PTSD症状升高的相关因素。相反,性虐待、租房居住、城市居住、言语虐待、压力性生活事件和躯体不适是男性抑郁、焦虑和PTSD症状的相关因素。与心理健康问题相关的因素包括社会支持、较高的主观幸福感、年龄较大(>50岁)、增加的剧烈运动和较高的家庭收入(男女均如此)。女性当前酒精使用的相关因素包括压力性生活事件、城市居住、性活跃和独居。在男性中,较高的家庭收入与当前酒精使用相关。与当前酒精使用相关的因素包括已婚、居住在大家庭(>5人)、是穆斯林和患有多种疾病(男女均如此)。当前药物使用的相关因素包括失业和性虐待。女性性别与当前药物使用几率降低相关。在研究环境中,抑郁、焦虑和PTSD症状以及酒精使用问题的患病率很高。然而,需求因性别和研究地点而异,突出了心理健康服务中针对性方法的重要性。我们的结果还强调了将心理健康服务纳入现有初级保健以及在该人群中测试和推广多成分心理健康干预措施的必要性。