Devoe L D, McKenzie J, Searle N, Sherline D M
Obstet Gynecol. 1985 Nov;66(5):617-20.
Despite the widespread use of the nonstress test, there has been no consensus on the criteria for normal reactivity. The authors studied 495 nonstress tests of 230 normal term fetuses, using a standardized protocol. The frequency distribution of movement-associated fetal heart rate (FHR) accelerations exceeding 15 beats per minute and 15 seconds' duration was examined in windows, ranging from ten to 40 minutes. Mean, median, and modal frequencies of movement-associated FHR accelerations were determined in 1910, 1418, 895, and 473 windows of ten, 20, 30, and 40 minutes, respectively. No significant difference in movement-associated FHR acceleration frequency was observed for any sequential ten-minute window, but movement-associated FHR accelerations were absent in 19.5, 8.8, 5.2, and 5.0% of 10-, 20-, 30-, and 40-minute windows, respectively. The broad frequency distributions of movement-associated FHR accelerations, produced by normal fetuses, precludes discrete diagnostic cutoffs in short time windows, unless one is willing to accept significant negative predictive errors.
尽管无应激试验被广泛应用,但对于正常反应性的标准尚未达成共识。作者采用标准化方案,对230例足月正常胎儿的495次无应激试验进行了研究。在10至40分钟的时间段内,以窗口形式检查了与胎动相关的胎儿心率(FHR)加速超过每分钟15次且持续15秒的频率分布。分别在1910个、1418个、895个和473个10分钟、20分钟、30分钟和40分钟的窗口中确定了与胎动相关的FHR加速的平均、中位数和众数频率。在任何连续的十分钟窗口中,均未观察到与胎动相关的FHR加速频率有显著差异,但在10分钟、20分钟、30分钟和40分钟的窗口中,分别有19.5%、8.8%、5.2%和5.0%的窗口未出现与胎动相关的FHR加速。正常胎儿产生的与胎动相关的FHR加速频率分布较宽,这排除了在短时间窗口内进行离散诊断阈值的可能性,除非愿意接受显著的阴性预测误差。