Tanigawa Kyoma, Shimizu Hiroki, Bandara Anuradhi, Toyota Misa, Suzuki Shota, Nagai-Tanima Momoko, Aoyama Tomoki
Department of Physical Therapy, Human Health Sciences, Graduate School of Medicine, Kyoto University, Kyoto, Japan.
PLoS One. 2025 Jul 3;20(7):e0327250. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0327250. eCollection 2025.
Walking is essential in daily life, and footwear type significantly affects walking patterns. High-heeled shoes increase the risk of knee osteoarthritis and falls in women. Traditional studies often use treadmills or unfamiliar footwear, which may not reflect daily walking. This study investigated the impact of high-heeled shoes on walking parameters in healthy adult women using in-shoe motion sensors.
Seventeen healthy adult women without pain during walking participated. They walked for 6 minutes along a 30-meter corridor wearing high-heeled shoes and sneakers. Walking data were recorded using an in-shoe motion sensor system every 2 minutes. The average of three valid consecutive steps was calculated automatically. Statistical analysis compared the mean walking parameters between the high-heel and sneaker groups.
The high-heel group showed significantly reduced foot clearance, stride length, peak plantar angle in dorsiflexion, and peak plantar angle in plantarflexion, and significantly greater toe-out angle in spatial parameters. Spatiotemporal parameters revealed significantly reduced walking speed and maximum swing phase speed in the high-heel group. No significant differences were observed in temporal parameters between the groups.
Since this study collected gait data under conditions similar to daily life, it provides data suitable for practical applications and may contribute to future research evaluating everyday gait. Additionally, future studies should include a broader range of participants and incorporate measurement devices capable of capturing hip and knee joint movements, providing a more comprehensive evaluation of the effects of high-heeled shoes on gait in healthy adult women.
行走在日常生活中至关重要,鞋类类型会显著影响行走模式。高跟鞋会增加女性患膝关节骨关节炎和跌倒的风险。传统研究通常使用跑步机或不熟悉的鞋类,这可能无法反映日常行走情况。本研究使用鞋内运动传感器调查了高跟鞋对健康成年女性行走参数的影响。
17名行走时无疼痛的健康成年女性参与了研究。她们穿着高跟鞋和运动鞋沿着一条30米长的走廊行走6分钟。使用鞋内运动传感器系统每2分钟记录一次行走数据。自动计算连续三个有效步幅的平均值。统计分析比较了高跟鞋组和运动鞋组之间的平均行走参数。
高跟鞋组在空间参数方面显示出足部离地间隙、步长、背屈时的足底峰值角度和跖屈时的足底峰值角度显著降低,以及外展角显著增大。时空参数显示高跟鞋组的行走速度和最大摆动相速度显著降低。两组之间在时间参数方面未观察到显著差异。
由于本研究在类似于日常生活的条件下收集了步态数据,它提供了适用于实际应用的数据,并可能有助于未来评估日常步态的研究。此外,未来的研究应纳入更广泛的参与者,并采用能够捕捉髋关节和膝关节运动的测量设备,以便更全面地评估高跟鞋对健康成年女性步态的影响。