O'Loughlin Erin K, Naja Mounia, Wellman Robert J, Maximova Katerina, O'Loughlin Jennifer L
Centre de Recherche du Centre Hospitalier de L'université de Montréal (CRCHUM), Montréal, Québec, Canada.
Faculty of Kinesiology and Physical Education, University of Toronto, Toronto, Ontario, Canada.
J Sch Health. 2025 Sep;95(9):710-722. doi: 10.1111/josh.70043. Epub 2025 Jul 3.
Availability and quality of nutrition-related health-promoting interventions (N-HPIs) vary across primary schools. We examined whether school contextual factors (e.g., socioeconomic deprivation) were associated with N-HPI availability in Quebec, Canada, and whether available N-HPIs incorporated evidence-based implementation characteristics.
In a cross-sectional study (2016-2019), informants from 171 primary schools reported on N-HPI availability. Availability was analyzed in relation to 10 school-level contextual indicators. A subset of 52 N-HPIs was examined in-depth for alignment with 15 evidence-based implementation characteristics identified in a literature review.
N-HPIs were reported in 120 schools (70%, including 77% serving disadvantaged populations). Among the 52 N-HPIs examined in-depth, over 75% demonstrated four core characteristics: Staff involvement, integration of multiple core competencies, innovative teaching strategies, and alignment with school context. Fewer HPIs included formal evaluation (46%), were delivered over multiple sessions (35%), or engaged students in design or implementation (15%).
To strengthen N-HPIs, policymakers should support flexible, theory-informed interventions that incorporate evaluation from the outset. Greater involvement of students, staff, and families in planning may help address persistent barriers.
While N-HPIs are widespread and often incorporate evidence-based implementation characteristics, there is room to enhance student participation, extend program duration, and strengthen evaluation.
营养相关健康促进干预措施(N-HPIs)在各小学的可获得性和质量存在差异。我们研究了学校背景因素(如社会经济剥夺情况)是否与加拿大魁北克省N-HPIs的可获得性相关,以及现有的N-HPIs是否具备基于证据的实施特征。
在一项横断面研究(2016 - 2019年)中,来自171所小学的信息提供者报告了N-HPIs的可获得性。分析了可获得性与10个学校层面背景指标的关系。对52项N-HPIs进行了深入研究,以考察其与文献综述中确定的15个基于证据的实施特征的一致性。
120所学校(70%)报告了N-HPIs(其中为弱势群体服务的学校占77%)。在深入研究的52项N-HPIs中,超过75%具备四个核心特征:员工参与、多种核心能力的整合、创新教学策略以及与学校背景的契合度。较少比例的健康促进干预措施包括正式评估(46%)、分多次进行(35%)或让学生参与设计或实施(15%)。
为加强N-HPIs,政策制定者应支持灵活的、基于理论且从一开始就纳入评估环节的干预措施。让学生、员工和家庭更多地参与规划可能有助于消除持续存在的障碍。
虽然N-HPIs广泛存在且通常具备基于证据的实施特征,但在提高学生参与度、延长项目持续时间和加强评估方面仍有提升空间。