Gruemer H D, Miller W G, Chinchilli V M, Leshner R T, Blasco P A, Hassler C R, Nance W E
Am J Clin Pathol. 1985 Nov;84(5):655-8. doi: 10.1093/ajcp/84.5.655.
Serum creatine kinase (CK) was measured in 515 healthy white women and 28 obligate carriers for Duchenne muscular dystrophy. There was substantial overlap between the control and carrier populations. To analyze the impact of the degree of overlap, the predictive value of a CK result was determined by (1) using sensitivity and specificity analysis, which assumes dichotomization into a positive or negative result based on a particular cut-off value; and (2) using likelihood ratio analysis, which evaluates an individual result based on the continuum observed for control and carrier populations. There was no clinically important difference whether an observed 57% or a hypothetical 33% overlap between control and carrier results was used. Because of the substantial overlap, the CK test utility is limited to those suspected carriers whose results fall above the healthy population interval. A low CK result does not provide sufficient assurance of noncarrier status.
对515名健康白人女性和28名杜氏肌营养不良症的 obligate携带者进行了血清肌酸激酶(CK)检测。对照组和携带者群体之间存在大量重叠。为了分析重叠程度的影响,通过以下两种方法确定CK检测结果的预测价值:(1)使用灵敏度和特异性分析,该方法基于特定的临界值将结果分为阳性或阴性;(2)使用似然比分析,该方法根据对照组和携带者群体观察到的连续数据评估个体结果。无论使用观察到的对照组和携带者结果之间57%的重叠率还是假设的33%的重叠率,均未发现临床上的重要差异。由于存在大量重叠,CK检测的效用仅限于那些检测结果高于健康人群区间的疑似携带者。CK检测结果较低并不能充分保证其非携带者状态。