Harrison G G
Ann Intern Med. 1985 Dec;103(6 ( Pt 2)):989-94. doi: 10.7326/0003-4819-103-6-989.
The concept of "desirable" weight derives from analyses of data in which relative body weight is correlated with mortality experience. "Ideal" or lowest-risk weights vary for different populations, and vary for the same population at different times and in relation to different causes of mortality. An ideal weight cannot be identified at a point in time for a person or persons differing from the groups on which desirable-weight tables were based. This fact, plus the limitations of existing tables and databases, has prompted some observers to suggest abandoning the concept of ideal weight. The recent publication of updated data for the U.S. population and updated height-weight tables based on actuarial data have focused attention on this issue. In addition, several studies have attempted to relate body weight to mortality in defined populations. At the same time, some studies have found significant relationships between overweight and mortality whereas others have not.
“理想”体重的概念源自对相关数据的分析,在这些数据中,相对体重与死亡经历相关。“理想”或最低风险体重因不同人群而异,并且同一人群在不同时间以及针对不同死亡原因也会有所不同。对于那些与制定理想体重表所依据的群体不同的个人,无法在某个时间点确定其理想体重。这一事实,再加上现有表格和数据库的局限性,促使一些观察家建议摒弃理想体重的概念。美国人口最新数据以及基于精算数据的更新后的身高体重表的近期发布,使得人们将注意力集中在这个问题上。此外,一些研究试图在特定人群中将体重与死亡率联系起来。与此同时,一些研究发现超重与死亡率之间存在显著关系,而另一些研究则未发现。