Omura Makiko, Venkatesh Mohini, Khandaker Ikhtiar, Rahman Ataur
Department of Economics, Faculty of Economics, Meiji Gakuin University, Tokyo, Japan.
Department of Education and Child Development, International Programs, Save the Children Federation, Inc., Fairfield, Connecticut, United States of America.
PLoS One. 2025 Jul 11;20(7):e0327325. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0327325. eCollection 2025.
This paper evaluates the impact of skill-based health education (SBHE) on children's hygiene practices and health in rural Bangladesh. Over one year, SBHE was delivered weekly to primary schools through a randomised-controlled trial (RCT) by locally recruited trained para-teachers. The SBHE and soap provision interventions, provided in a cross-cutting manner, were randomly assigned to 180 schools stratified by two school types. Data were collected at both the school and child levels, involving 40 students in grades 1-4 at baseline and expanding to 50 students in grades 1-5 at endline, ten students per grade. The study tracked the same pupils, supplemented by additional and replacement students, resulting in effective sample sizes of 7,192 at baseline and 8,992 at endline. The results indicate that SBHE significantly improved hygiene practices; the average treatment effects on overall hygiene practices was 0.22 SD [0.14-0.31] (p < 0.001), and those on health/hygiene knowledge was 0.44 SD [0.33-0.55] (p < 0.001). While improvements in cold-related symptoms among the SBHE school children were marginally significant (-0.05 SD [-0.10, -0.01], p = 0.09), the overall trends indicated general improvement in health as well as healthy behaviours across all schools, irrespective of treatment status. Additional analysis incorporating inter-school spillover effects provided robust evidence of beneficial healthy practice externalities, extending beyond treatment school children. A cross-cutting soap provision treatment, although implemented imperfectly, did not show any standalone positive health-related effects. Nonetheless, our cost-effectiveness analysis indicated the economic viability of SBHE, particularly when accounting for spillover effects. This study is registered in the AEA RCT registry (No.0004265) and the ISRCTN registry (No.18002856).
本文评估了基于技能的健康教育(SBHE)对孟加拉国农村地区儿童卫生习惯及健康状况的影响。在一年多的时间里,通过当地招聘并经过培训的助理教师,以随机对照试验(RCT)的方式每周向小学提供SBHE。以交叉方式提供的SBHE和肥皂供应干预措施,被随机分配到按两种学校类型分层的180所学校。在学校和儿童层面收集了数据,基线时涉及1-4年级的40名学生,终期时扩展到1-5年级的50名学生,每个年级10名。该研究跟踪了相同的学生,并补充了额外的和替代的学生,基线时有效样本量为7192,终期时为8992。结果表明,SBHE显著改善了卫生习惯;对总体卫生习惯的平均治疗效果为0.22标准差[0.14 - 0.31](p < 0.001),对健康/卫生知识的平均治疗效果为0.44标准差[0.33 - 0.55](p < 0.001)。虽然SBHE学校儿童中与感冒相关症状的改善略显显著(-0.05标准差[-0.10, -0.01],p = 0.09),但总体趋势表明,无论治疗状况如何,所有学校的健康状况以及健康行为都普遍有所改善。纳入校际溢出效应的额外分析提供了有力证据,证明有益的健康行为外部性不仅限于接受治疗的学童。交叉的肥皂供应治疗虽然实施得并不完美,但并未显示出任何独立的与健康相关的积极效果。尽管如此,我们的成本效益分析表明了SBHE的经济可行性,特别是在考虑溢出效应时。本研究已在AEA RCT注册库(编号0004265)和ISRCTN注册库(编号18002856)中登记。