Calvert Collin, Taylor Stephanie L, Olson Juli, Coggeshall Scott S, Frochen Stephen, Zeliadt Steven B, Taylor Brent C, Burgess Diana J
Center for Care Delivery and Outcomes Research, Minneapolis VA Health Care System, Minneapolis, MN, USA.
University of Minnesota Medical School, Minneapolis, MN, USA.
Glob Adv Integr Med Health. 2025 Jul 8;14:27536130251358757. doi: 10.1177/27536130251358757. eCollection 2025 Jan-Dec.
Complementary and Integrative Health (CIH) services are a national priority for the Department of Veterans Affairs (VA) healthcare system and can be effective in reducing chronic pain. Eligible VA patients can receive their CIH care through a VA clinic, or through community care (CC) funded by the VA. The present study compares the effectiveness of 3 CIH services (acupuncture, chiropractic, and medical massage therapy) delivered in direct care by VA vs CC providers at improving veterans' chronic pain.
Data were analyzed from the Complementary and Integrative Health Therapy Patient Experience Survey, a longitudinal, self-administered survey of CIH use and health outcomes. Mixed models were used to evaluate the relationship of higher CIH therapy visits delivered by the VA vs CC with pain interference and pain severity, using both raw counts of visits and clinically meaningful groupings of visits.
Among veterans with chronic pain who engaged in CIH services, more CIH visits were associated with lower levels of pain severity and pain interference. VA acupuncture and chiropractic had a stronger beneficial relationship with pain than CC acupuncture and chiropractic, while CC medical massage therapy had a stronger beneficial relationship than VA medical massage.
CIH therapies delivered through the VA and through CC both offer potentially effective means of reducing chronic pain. Some therapies may be more effective when delivered through the VA vs CC, or may indicate lack of full implementation, but the limitations of observational data preclude any causal statements.
补充与整合健康(CIH)服务是美国退伍军人事务部(VA)医疗保健系统的一项国家优先事项,并且在减轻慢性疼痛方面可能有效。符合条件的VA患者可以通过VA诊所或通过VA资助的社区护理(CC)接受CIH护理。本研究比较了VA与CC提供者直接提供的3种CIH服务(针灸、脊椎按摩疗法和医疗按摩疗法)在改善退伍军人慢性疼痛方面的有效性。
对补充与整合健康治疗患者体验调查的数据进行了分析,这是一项关于CIH使用和健康结果的纵向、自我管理的调查。使用混合模型来评估VA与CC提供的更多CIH治疗就诊次数与疼痛干扰和疼痛严重程度之间的关系,使用就诊次数的原始计数和具有临床意义的就诊分组。
在接受CIH服务的慢性疼痛退伍军人中,更多的CIH就诊次数与较低水平的疼痛严重程度和疼痛干扰相关。VA针灸和脊椎按摩疗法与疼痛的有益关系比CC针灸和脊椎按摩疗法更强,而CC医疗按摩疗法比VA医疗按摩疗法的有益关系更强。
通过VA和CC提供的CIH疗法都提供了减轻慢性疼痛的潜在有效手段。某些疗法通过VA与CC提供时可能更有效,或者可能表明缺乏全面实施,但观察性数据的局限性排除了任何因果陈述。