Chávez-Martínez Omar
Instituto Mexicano del Seguro Social, Coordinación de Investigación en Salud, División de Investigación Clínica. Ciudad de México, México.
Rev Med Inst Mex Seguro Soc. 2025 Jul 1;63(4):e6384. doi: 10.5281/zenodo.15644343.
Accuracy in bibliographic references is a fundamental aspect of scientific communication, particularly in the health sciences, where knowledge traceability carries clinical, ethical, and educational implications. This article analyzes the limitations of the Vancouver style in its editorial implementation and argues for the standardization of the NLM format as a common technical framework. Through a critical review of the literature, it identifies frequent problems resulting from the multiplicity of citation styles, such as referencing errors, ambiguity in editorial policies, and deficiencies in academic training on citation practices. Empirical studies are presented that highlight the low accuracy of references generated by reference managers without supervision, as well as the inconsistency of citation criteria among biomedical journal editors. The article proposes specific institutional actions, including incorporating reference quality into thesis evaluation rubrics, formalizing the librarian's role in the editorial review process, and developing unified citation guidelines. It also emphasizes the need for an educational approach that goes beyond mechanical style application and fosters a critical understanding of citation as an ethical and strategic practice. The article concludes that the adoption of the NLM format, supported by specialized training and institutional policies, would enhance transparency, efficiency, and reliability in biomedical scientific publishing.
参考文献的准确性是科学交流的一个基本方面,在健康科学领域尤为如此,因为知识的可追溯性具有临床、伦理和教育意义。本文分析了温哥华格式在编辑实施中的局限性,并主张将美国国立医学图书馆(NLM)格式标准化为一个通用的技术框架。通过对文献的批判性综述,本文指出了由于多种引用格式导致的常见问题,如引用错误、编辑政策的模糊性以及引用实践学术培训的不足。文中展示的实证研究突出了未经监督的参考文献管理工具生成的参考文献准确性较低,以及生物医学期刊编辑之间引用标准的不一致性。本文提出了具体的机构行动,包括将参考文献质量纳入论文评估标准、明确图书馆员在编辑评审过程中的作用以及制定统一的引用指南。本文还强调了一种教育方法的必要性,这种方法不仅要机械地应用格式,还要培养对引用作为一种伦理和策略性实践的批判性理解。本文得出结论,在专业培训和机构政策的支持下采用NLM格式,将提高生物医学科学出版的透明度、效率和可靠性。