Suryadevara Manika, Wang Dongliang, Domachowske Joseph
Department of Pediatrics, SUNY Upstate Medical University, Syracuse, NY, USA.
Department of Public Health and Preventive Medicine, SUNY Upstate Medical University, Syracuse, NY, USA.
Hum Vaccin Immunother. 2025 Dec;21(1):2529635. doi: 10.1080/21645515.2025.2529635. Epub 2025 Jul 16.
Consistency of the healthcare delivery team's communication to families is influential in vaccine decision-making. We aim to describe personal vaccine practices, attitudes, and literacy among New York State primary care office providers and personnel. We disseminated an anonymous survey to providers and office personnel (including but not limited to front office staff, medical assistance, nurses, advanced practice providers, and physicians) of 12 primary care practices between May and July 2023. Responses were assessed using chi-square tests, t-tests, and one way ANOVA tests to compare categorical variables, the means between two groups, and means across multiple groups, respectively. 216 respondents completed the survey. 25/213 (12%) and 16/147 (11%) reported declining routinely recommended vaccine(s) for themselves or for their child(ren), respectively, most commonly the COVID-19 and/or influenza vaccines. Less than three-quarters of respondents strongly agreed with the following statements: vaccines are safe to administer to children (149/214, 70%), vaccines are safe to administer to adolescents (149/213, 70%), and vaccines are effective in preventing disease (146/213, 69%). In total, 149/213 (70%) and 89/211 (42%) of respondents report that parents express concerns to them about vaccines in the clinic and outside of the practice setting, respectively, yet just over half of the respondents (116/210, 55%) report strong agreement with being comfortable having vaccine conversations with parents. Vaccine hesitancy exists across all healthcare team roles. Practice-wide education regarding vaccine safety, efficacy and importance and strategies for communicating about vaccines with patients and families is needed to improve vaccine confidence among the healthcare teams and patients.
医疗服务团队与家庭沟通的一致性对疫苗决策有影响。我们旨在描述纽约州初级保健办公室提供者和工作人员的个人疫苗接种行为、态度和知识水平。2023年5月至7月期间,我们向12家初级保健机构的提供者和办公室工作人员(包括但不限于前台工作人员、医疗助理、护士、高级执业提供者和医生)发放了一份匿名调查问卷。分别使用卡方检验、t检验和单因素方差分析来评估回答,以比较分类变量、两组之间的均值以及多组之间的均值。216名受访者完成了调查。25/213(12%)和16/147(11%)的受访者分别报告称自己或其子女拒绝常规推荐的疫苗,最常见的是新冠疫苗和/或流感疫苗。不到四分之三的受访者强烈同意以下陈述:给儿童接种疫苗是安全的(149/214,70%)、给青少年接种疫苗是安全的(149/213,70%)以及疫苗能有效预防疾病(146/213,69%)。总体而言,1:9/213(70%)和89/211(42%)的受访者报告称,家长分别在诊所和医疗机构之外向他们表达了对疫苗的担忧,但只有略超过一半的受访者(116/210,55%)报告强烈同意自己乐于与家长进行疫苗相关的对话。所有医疗团队角色中都存在疫苗犹豫现象。需要在整个医疗机构范围内开展关于疫苗安全性、有效性和重要性的教育,以及与患者和家庭就疫苗进行沟通的策略,以提高医疗团队和患者对疫苗的信心。