Staples Naomi, Collett James, Gild Matti, Hong Jonathan, Huq Fawzia, Shone Jennifer, Scott Karen M
Education Office, Sydney Medical School, Faculty of Medicine and Health, University of Sydney, Sydney, Australia.
Dubbo Clinical School, Sydney Medical School, Faculty of Medicine and Health, University of Sydney; Dubbo Hospital, Sydney, Australia.
Clin Teach. 2025 Aug;22(4):e70156. doi: 10.1111/tct.70156.
Emphasis is being placed on producing intern-ready graduates who can navigate complex clinical environments. Early clinical immersion seeks to enable this through experiential learning and supported participation in authentic workplaces; however, its educational value remains intangible. Studies have evaluated placement objectives but not other effects in detail. We explored novice students' experiences and approaches to learning during early clinical immersion and factors that enhanced or hindered them.
Medical students at the beginning of their second year undertook 8 weeks of immersive clinical learning to introduce them to hospital settings, enable understanding of hospital workplaces and strengthen clinical assessment and skills. In 2021, focus groups were conducted and data were analysed using theory-informing subjectivist inductive data analysis based on self-regulation learning theory.
Fifteen participants described diverse experiences and approaches to learning during early clinical immersion, indicating varying degrees of self-regulated learning. Through goal setting, strategic awareness and behaviour, self-reflection and adaptation and flexibility, some maximised learning opportunities, while others had a more limited experience. Some causal attributes enhanced learning, such as undertaking ward-based learning tasks with nurses, while other attributes hindered it, such as disengaged supervisors and teams.
The quality of students' experience of learning during early clinical immersion is influenced by the degree of self-regulated learning, which affects the approach to learning, plus system barriers and facilitators. Strategies that enable students to enhance self-regulated learning, such as setting and monitoring learning goals with supervisors, may help optimise learning in clinical environments and provide the scaffolds to enhance learning.
目前正着重培养能够适应复杂临床环境的实习就绪型毕业生。早期临床沉浸旨在通过体验式学习和在真实工作场所的支持性参与来实现这一目标;然而,其教育价值仍难以捉摸。已有研究评估了实习目标,但未详细评估其他影响。我们探讨了新手学生在早期临床沉浸期间的学习经历、学习方法以及促进或阻碍他们学习的因素。
二年级医学生进行了为期8周的沉浸式临床学习,以让他们了解医院环境,理解医院工作场所,并强化临床评估和技能。2021年,我们开展了焦点小组讨论,并基于自我调节学习理论,采用理论导向的主观主义归纳数据分析方法对数据进行了分析。
15名参与者描述了早期临床沉浸期间多样的学习经历和方法,表明他们的自我调节学习程度各不相同。通过目标设定、策略意识与行为、自我反思以及适应与灵活性,一些人最大限度地利用了学习机会,而另一些人的经历则较为有限。一些因果属性促进了学习,比如与护士一起承担基于病房的学习任务,而其他属性则起到了阻碍作用,比如不投入的带教老师和团队。
早期临床沉浸期间学生的学习体验质量受自我调节学习程度的影响,自我调节学习程度又影响学习方法,此外还受系统障碍和促进因素的影响。让学生增强自我调节学习的策略,比如与带教老师设定并监控学习目标,可能有助于优化临床环境中的学习,并提供促进学习的支架。