Mizutani Mayumi, Bando Harumi, Oktaviani Sofi, Nishitani Naoko, Nishimura Junko, Nishide Ritsuko, Tanimura Susumu
Department of Integrated Health Sciences, Nagoya University Graduate School of Medicine, Aichi, Japan.
Faculty of Nursing, School of Medicine, Nara Medical University, Nara, Japan.
Prev Med Rep. 2025 Jun 15;56:103139. doi: 10.1016/j.pmedr.2025.103139. eCollection 2025 Aug.
The positive deviance approach is a community-based strategy that promotes behavioral and social change to improve health outcomes and demonstrates effectiveness even in resource-limited settings. Although the number of scientific studies on positive deviance has increased, comprehensive quantitative assessments of its overall trends remain lacking. This study conducted a bibliometric analysis to analyze global trends and key themes in positive deviance research within public health over the past 50 years (1976-2024).
We used data from Scopus and Web of Science, examining publications including the term "positive devian*" alongside "public health" or "community health." The analysis covered articles and reviews published from 1976 to 2024. Additionally, we conducted descriptive analysis, network analysis, and thematic mapping.
We identified 319 publications in 219 journals in the studied period. Contributions were made from 45 countries, including 25 low- or middle-income countries (55.6 %). Notably, 106 papers (33.2 %) and 30 countries (66.7 %) involved international collaboration, with the United States leading in both productivity and collaboration. Thematic mapping indicated that high-income countries prioritized motor themes (well-developed, relevant thematic areas) such as "obesity" and "resilience" and emerging themes like "quality improvement" and "primary care." Conversely, lower-income countries focused on motor themes like "stunting" and "wasting" and emerging themes like "qualitative" research and "malaria."
There is a rising global interest in positive deviance, as evidenced by increasing publication volume, participation from lower-income countries, and strengthened international collaborations. Focusing on underexplored themes could help shape the direction of future positive deviance research in public health.
积极偏差方法是一种基于社区的策略,可促进行为和社会变革以改善健康结果,并且即使在资源有限的环境中也显示出有效性。尽管关于积极偏差的科学研究数量有所增加,但仍缺乏对其总体趋势的全面定量评估。本研究进行了文献计量分析,以分析过去50年(1976 - 2024年)公共卫生领域积极偏差研究的全球趋势和关键主题。
我们使用了Scopus和科学网的数据,检索包含“积极偏差*”以及“公共卫生”或“社区卫生”的出版物。分析涵盖了1976年至2024年发表的文章和综述。此外,我们还进行了描述性分析、网络分析和主题映射。
在研究期间,我们在219种期刊中确定了319篇出版物。来自45个国家做出了贡献,其中包括25个低收入或中等收入国家(55.6%)。值得注意的是,106篇论文(33.2%)和30个国家(66.7%)参与了国际合作,美国在生产力和合作方面均领先。主题映射表明,高收入国家优先考虑诸如“肥胖”和“复原力”等成熟主题(发展良好、相关的主题领域)以及“质量改进”和“初级保健”等新兴主题。相反,低收入国家关注诸如“发育迟缓”和“消瘦”等成熟主题以及“定性”研究和“疟疾”等新兴主题。
全球对积极偏差的兴趣正在上升,这体现在出版物数量的增加、低收入国家的参与以及国际合作的加强。关注未充分探索的主题有助于塑造未来公共卫生领域积极偏差研究的方向。