Chrdle Aleš, Bártlová Sylva, Chloubová Ivana
Faculty of Health and Social Sciences, University of South Bohemia in České Budějovice, Department of Infectious Diseases, České Budějovice Hospital, Inc., Czech Republic, e-mail:
Klin Mikrobiol Infekc Lek. 2025 Mar;31(1):11-18.
Correct and safe use of personal protective equipment (PPE) is a basic competency for nurses. We asked doctors about the level of knowledge, skills, and proficiency they observed in nurses when using PPE in their workplace during the COVID-19 pandemic.
The study had a descriptive, cross-sectional design. Representative sociological research was performed. Data were collected via a non-standardized questionnaire. The study aimed to identify doctors' views on nurses' competency in using PPE, divided into three domains: knowledge, skills, and proficiency. Data were collected using a standardized structured interview with respondents in the Czech Republic from 28 November to 18 December 2022, by 230 inter-viewers from the INRES-SONES agency. Out of 1 410 randomly selected doctors, 1 203 (85.3 %) agreed to participate in the study. This sample was representative of doctors in Czechia with respect to gender, age, and region.
Of the 1 203 responding doctors, 243 (20.2 %) worked most of their time in COVID-19-dedicated units, 369 (30.7 %) in primary care and 591 (49.1 %) in units with low numbers of COVID-19 patients. The majority of the 1 203 respondents fully or partially agreed that nurses in their workplace had the necessary knowledge (87.6 %), skills (86.4 %), and proficiency (78.3 %) when using PPE. A significantly higher proportion of doctors who were not satisfied with the nurses' level of competency was noted among those who were younger and worked in hospital wards, especially in COVID-19-dedicated units.
After more than two years of using PPE, one out of seven respondents stated that nurses in their workplace had less than the necessary knowledge (12.4 %) or skills (13.6 %). One-fifth of doctors (21.7 %) did not agree that nurses in their workplace had the necessary proficiency to use PPE properly. While respondents in private practice and primary care e usually trained nurses in PPE use and procured PPE, the lack of control over PPE procurement and training processes in COVID-19-dedicated units might have caused the lower level of satisfaction. The cross-sectional design of the study did not allow for a deeper analysis of the factors that led doctors to disagree with the statement that nurses in their workplace had sufficient knowledge, skills, and proficiency in using PPE.
Acquiring the necessary knowledge, skills, and proficiency in using PPE should be part of the undergraduate and postgraduate training of nurses, as well as part of the plans for the preparedness of healthcare teams for any future viral respiratory pandemic.
正确且安全地使用个人防护装备(PPE)是护士的一项基本能力。我们询问了医生,关于在新冠疫情期间,他们观察到护士在工作场所使用个人防护装备时的知识、技能和熟练程度水平。
该研究采用描述性横断面设计。进行了具有代表性的社会学研究。通过非标准化问卷收集数据。该研究旨在确定医生对护士使用个人防护装备能力的看法,分为三个领域:知识、技能和熟练程度。2022年11月28日至12月18日,由INRES - SONES机构的230名访谈员对捷克共和国的受访者进行标准化结构化访谈,收集数据。在随机抽取的1410名医生中,1203名(85.3%)同意参与该研究。这个样本在性别、年龄和地区方面代表了捷克的医生。
在1203名回复的医生中,243名(20.2%)大部分时间在新冠专用病房工作,369名(30.7%)在初级保健机构工作,591名(49.1%)在新冠患者数量较少的病房工作。1203名受访者中的大多数完全或部分同意,他们工作场所的护士在使用个人防护装备时具备必要的知识(87.6%)、技能(86.4%)和熟练程度(78.3%)。在年轻医生以及在医院病房工作的医生中,特别是在新冠专用病房工作的医生中,对护士能力水平不满意的比例明显更高。
在使用个人防护装备两年多后,七分之一的受访者表示,他们工作场所的护士所具备的知识(12.4%)或技能(13.6%)不足。五分之一的医生(21.7%)不同意他们工作场所的护士具备正确使用个人防护装备的必要熟练程度。虽然私人执业和初级保健机构的受访者通常会对护士进行个人防护装备使用培训并采购个人防护装备,但新冠专用病房对个人防护装备采购和培训过程缺乏控制可能导致了较低的满意度。该研究的横断面设计不允许对导致医生不同意其工作场所的护士在使用个人防护装备方面具备足够知识、技能和熟练程度这一说法的因素进行更深入的分析。
获取使用个人防护装备的必要知识、技能和熟练程度应成为护士本科和研究生培训的一部分,以及医疗团队为未来任何病毒性呼吸道大流行做准备计划的一部分。