Wuni Abubakari, Musah Ajara, Sisala Iddrisu Mohammed, Abdulai Abdul Malik, Chanayireh Letitia, Nyarko Brenda Abena, Buasilenu Hannah, Mohammed Ibrahim Mudasir, Musah Sulemana, Azure Dorothy, Abdulai Nafisah
Department of Medicine for the Elderly (C6), Cambridge University Hospitals NHS Foundation Addenbrookes Hospital, Cambridge, UK.
Nurses' and Midwives' Training College, Tamale, Ghana.
Nurs Open. 2025 Jul;12(7):e70282. doi: 10.1002/nop2.70282.
Workplace bullying is an important issue confronting the nursing profession, with victims described as being part of an oppressed group. The number of attacks and acts of violence that staff direct at each other in the workplace is alarmingly high and cannot be ignored.
This study assessed the prevalence and impact of workplace bullying of nurses by other nurses among those working in three major hospitals in the Tamale Metropolis, Ghana.
Data for this study were collected from Tamale Teaching Hospital, Tamale Central Hospital, and Tamale West Hospital using a descriptive cross-sectional multi-facility study design with a quantitative approach to data collection. A proportionate stratified random sampling technique was used to recruit 338 nurses from the three hospitals. A structured questionnaire was used to collect data, following approval from the Tamale Teaching Hospital Research and Development Unit and the Northern Regional Health Directorate, from January 2022 to March 2022. Stata for Windows V16.0 was used to analyse the data. Bivariate and multivariable logistic regression models were used to explore the factors associated with the prevalence of perceived workplace bullying among nurses. Confidence intervals were computed at a 95% confidence level, and a p-value of 0.05 or less was considered statistically significant.
The majority of respondents (85.5%) indicated they had observed workplace bullying before, and 50.6% had witnessed the bullying of a nurse by another nurse. A little over one-third had been victims of workplace bullying. Females constituted a higher proportion of both the perpetrators (53.0%) and the main targets (80.2%) of workplace bullying. Additionally, 34.6% reported having the intention to travel abroad to practise nursing as a result of observing bullying or being victims themselves. Multivariable analysis showed that the odds of experiencing workplace bullying were 63% lower among nurses working in the surgical ward compared to those in the Outpatient Department (AOR: 0.37, 95% CI: 0.15-0.91, p = 0.030).
This study revealed that workplace bullying is prevalent among nurses in the three main hospitals within the Tamale Metropolis. Most respondents had witnessed workplace bullying, and a little over one-third had been victims themselves. Workplace bullying is a measurable issue that negatively affects nurses' mental health and job performance. Therefore, nursing leaders should organise regular sensitisation programmes to raise awareness of the impact of workplace bullying. Additionally, hospital management should encourage nurses to report instances of bullying, establish disciplinary committees to address such cases, punish offenders, and protect those who witness or are victims of bullying.
职场霸凌是护理行业面临的一个重要问题,受害者被视为受压迫群体的一部分。工作人员在工作场所相互攻击和暴力行为的数量高得惊人,不容忽视。
本研究评估了加纳塔马利市三家主要医院护士中护士之间职场霸凌的发生率及其影响。
本研究的数据收集自塔马利教学医院、塔马利中心医院和塔马利西部医院,采用描述性横断面多机构研究设计以及定量数据收集方法。使用按比例分层随机抽样技术从这三家医院招募了338名护士。在获得塔马利教学医院研发部门和北部地区卫生局批准后,于2022年1月至2022年3月使用结构化问卷收集数据。使用Windows版Stata V16.0分析数据。采用双变量和多变量逻辑回归模型探讨与护士中感知到的职场霸凌发生率相关的因素。在95%置信水平计算置信区间,p值小于或等于0.05被认为具有统计学意义。
大多数受访者(85.5%)表示他们之前观察到职场霸凌,50.6%目睹过护士被另一名护士霸凌。略超过三分之一的人曾是职场霸凌的受害者。女性在职场霸凌的实施者(53.0%)和主要目标对象(80.2%)中占比更高。此外,34.6%的人报告称,由于目睹霸凌行为或自己成为受害者,他们打算出国从事护理工作。多变量分析显示,与门诊部门的护士相比,外科病房的护士遭受职场霸凌的几率低63%(调整后比值比:0.37,95%置信区间:0.15 - 0.91,p = 0.030)。
本研究表明,职场霸凌在塔马利市三家主要医院的护士中普遍存在。大多数受访者目睹过职场霸凌,略超过三分之一的人自己曾是受害者。职场霸凌是一个可衡量的问题,会对护士的心理健康和工作表现产生负面影响。因此,护理领导应定期组织宣传活动,提高对职场霸凌影响的认识。此外,医院管理层应鼓励护士举报霸凌事件,设立纪律委员会处理此类案件,惩罚违规者,并保护那些目睹霸凌或成为受害者的人。