Murnan Aaron, England Gwen, Matthews Caneacha, Boch Sam, Qasem Islam, Bates Samantha, Manchak Sarah
Department of Population Health, College of Nursing, University of Cincinnati, 3110 Vine Street, Cincinnati, OH, USA, 45219.
Creating Autonomy Through Collaborative Healing (CATCH) Specialty Docket Court Program, Franklin County Municipal Court, 375 S High Street, Columbus, OH, 43215.
J Hum Traffick. 2024 Mar 5. doi: 10.1080/23322705.2024.2321091.
Sex trafficking specialty court programs represent a structural approach to disrupt historic patterns of violence, health disparities, as well as counteract carceral recidivism issues. Despite the promise of these programs, inequities have been observed in women's access, entry, and success within such programs. The purpose of the current study was to understand perceptions and experiences underlying documented racial disparities in women's access to and retention within sex trafficking specialty court programs. Fifteen black women with histories of arrest for prostitution or solicitation were recruited to participate in interviews querying experiences with referral processes, factors associated with their admittance and retention, and factors influencing whether they ultimately participated in such a program. An inductive content analysis was used to analyze interview transcript data. Four groups of themes emerged after analyses: (a) perceptions and experiences with police and the criminal legal system; (b) perceptions of sex trafficking specialty court programs; (c) perceived barriers to participation; and (d) perceived facilitators of participation. This research provides meaningful context towards perceptions and experiences underlying previously observed disparities in women's referral to and success within sex trafficking specialty court programs. Findings provide insights towards practices that could bolster equity within these programs.
性交易特别法庭项目是一种结构性方法,旨在打破暴力、健康差距的历史模式,并应对监禁累犯问题。尽管这些项目前景广阔,但在女性参与此类项目的机会、进入项目以及在项目中取得成功方面,仍存在不平等现象。本研究的目的是了解女性在性交易特别法庭项目中的参与机会和留存率方面,记录在案的种族差异背后的认知和经历。招募了15名有因卖淫或拉客被捕历史的黑人女性参与访谈,询问她们在转介过程中的经历、与她们被接纳和留存相关的因素,以及影响她们最终是否参与此类项目的因素。采用归纳式内容分析法对访谈转录数据进行分析。分析后出现了四组主题:(a) 对警察和刑事法律系统的认知和经历;(b) 对性交易特别法庭项目的认知;(c) 参与的感知障碍;(d) 参与的感知促进因素。本研究为先前观察到的女性在性交易特别法庭项目中的转介和成功方面的差异背后的认知和经历提供了有意义的背景。研究结果为可加强这些项目公平性的实践提供了见解。