Chen Hong, Cheng Yu, Diao Ke, Wang YiFan, An Jing, Zhang Haijiang, Li RongRong, Zhang Dan, Cheng SuMian, Zhang Minglian, Wang LiFei
Hebei Province Key Laboratory of Ophthalmology, Hebei Eye Hospital, Hebei Clinical Research Center for Ocular Diseases, Xingtai, China.
Department of Ophthalmology, Teaching and Research Office, Hebei Medical University, Shijiazhuang, China.
Front Med (Lausanne). 2025 Jul 8;12:1502787. doi: 10.3389/fmed.2025.1502787. eCollection 2025.
This article discussed the repeatability and coefficient of variation (CV) of flash visual evoked potential (FVEP) and full-field electroretinogram (ffERG) indicators of different eyes, individuals, and time points of normal male Sprague-Dawley rats, providing a reference for selecting a reasonable control scheme for retinal and optic nerve disease rat models.
Twenty normal 6-8 week Sprague-Dawley rats were selected, from which 10 randomly chosen rats underwent ffERG examination and the other 10 underwent FVEP examination. At different time points (1 d, 7 d), Roland visual electrophysiological device was utilized to record in FVEP P2 peak time and N2-P2 amplitude, peak time and amplitude of dark-adapted 0.01 ERG b-wave, peak time and amplitude of dark-adapted 3.0 ERG a- and b-waves, OPs OS2 amplitude, peak time and amplitude of light-adapted 3.0 ERG a- and b-waves, and N1-P1 amplitude of light-adapted 3.0 flash ERG. Meanwhile, we also analyzed the mean ± standard deviation, range, and CV, as well as compared mean ± standard deviation, range, and CV values between two eyes of the same rat and monocular results before and after intervention.
Stable waveforms could be recorded for each rat. Among them, the smallest CV was obtained at the peak time of the FVEP P2 wave (10.1%), while that of amplitude in the VEP P2 wave was relatively large (41.2%). In the ffERG examination, the CV value at each peak time was relatively small (12.9% -39.8%), while the CV value for each wave amplitude was relatively large (33.4% -93.5%). In each waveform, the lower the amplitude, the greater the CV value. By comparing the three control schemes, the CV at the P2 peak time of FVEP examination generated using the baseline ratio approach was the smallest, and that of amplitude calculated using the absolute value approach was the smallest. In the ffERG examination, except for the light-adapted 3.0 ERG a-wave with the lowest CV obtained by the baseline ratio method (57.7%), the CV values of the other examination items were as follows: OD/OS ratio method<absolute value method<baseline ratio method. The CV at each peak time generated by the baseline ratio method was the highest.
In normal adult male Sprague-Dawley rats, the optic nerve function assessment at P2 wave peak time in FVEP is the most stable, and the CV of N2-P2 amplitude is relatively large. During retinal function assessment by ffERG, the detection error for different eyes of the same individual<different individuals<different time points, which can be reduced using a reasonable control scheme.
本文探讨正常雄性Sprague-Dawley大鼠不同眼睛、个体及时间点的闪光视觉诱发电位(FVEP)和全视野视网膜电图(ffERG)指标的重复性及变异系数(CV),为视网膜和视神经疾病大鼠模型选择合理的对照方案提供参考。
选取20只6 - 8周龄的正常Sprague-Dawley大鼠,随机选取10只大鼠进行ffERG检查,另外10只进行FVEP检查。在不同时间点(1天、7天),使用罗兰视觉电生理设备记录FVEP的P2峰时间和N2 - P2波幅、暗适应0.01 ERG b波的峰时间和波幅、暗适应3.0 ERG a波和b波的峰时间和波幅、OPs OS2波幅、明适应3.0 ERG a波和b波的峰时间和波幅以及明适应3.0闪光ERG的N1 - P1波幅。同时,分析均值±标准差、范围和CV,并比较同一只大鼠两只眼睛之间以及干预前后单眼结果的均值±标准差、范围和CV值。
每只大鼠均可记录到稳定的波形。其中,FVEP的P2波峰时间的CV最小(10.1%),而VEP的P2波波幅的CV相对较大(41.2%)。在ffERG检查中,各峰时间的CV值相对较小(12.9% - 39.8%),而各波波幅的CV值相对较大(33.4% - 93.5%)。在每个波形中,波幅越低,CV值越大。通过比较三种对照方案,基线比值法用于FVEP检查时P2峰时间的CV最小,绝对值法计算波幅时的CV最小。在ffERG检查中,除明适应3.0 ERG a波基线比值法获得的CV最低(57.7%)外,其他检查项目的CV值排序为:OD/OS比值法<绝对值法<基线比值法。基线比值法在各峰时间产生的CV最高。
在正常成年雄性Sprague-Dawley大鼠中,FVEP的P2波峰时间对视神经功能的评估最稳定,N2 - P2波幅的CV相对较大。在通过ffERG评估视网膜功能时,同一个体不同眼睛<不同个体<不同时间点的检测误差,可采用合理的对照方案减小误差。