Magnano San Lio Roberta, Morini Mara, Di Rosa Enrico, Sinopoli Alessandra, Casigliani Virginia, Martella Manuela, Maugeri Andrea, Barchitta Martina, Agodi Maria Carmela, Picardi Ilenia, Agodi Antonella
Department of Medical and Surgical Sciences and Advanced Technologies "GF Ingrassia", University of Catania, Catania, Italy.
Gender Prevention Working Group, Italian Society of Hygiene, Preventive Medicine, and Public Health (SItI), Rome, Italy.
PLoS One. 2025 Jul 23;20(7):e0325705. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0325705. eCollection 2025.
Gender equality remains a key focus in research and innovation policies. However, the academic sector still exhibits significant under-representation of women in leadership roles and horizontal segregation affecting career trajectories. This study examines gender inequalities in top positions and career progression within Italy's Medical Sciences sector (Area 06) from 2014 to 2023, through data from the Cineca portal, including details on academic roles, gender, region, and scientific-disciplinary sectors (SSDs). Gender disparity was evaluated using the Glass Ceiling Index (GCI) and the Glass Door Index (GDI). Data analysis up to 2023 shows a gender inversion in career progression: women dominate early career stages - accounted for 71.5% of research fellows and 57.1% of RTDA positions -, but men prevail in senior roles, with 61.8% associate professors and 71.8% full professors. This trend is consistent across most SSDs. Although temporal analysis indicates a reduction in gender disparities in top positions - with a GCI ranging from 2.3 in 2015 to 1.7 in 2023 - GCI values above one across all regions suggest persistent gender inequality. The GDI values, ranging from 1.3 in 2015 to 1.6 in 2023, exhibit considerable variability; however, overall, the disparities have worsened by 2023. These findings underscore the need for concrete measures to enhance equity and inclusivity in academia. Developing and implementing initiatives, programs, and policies that guarantee equal opportunities and resources for all researchers, irrespective of gender, is essential.
性别平等仍然是研究与创新政策的关键重点。然而,学术领域中女性担任领导职务的比例仍然显著偏低,且存在影响职业发展轨迹的横向隔离现象。本研究通过Cineca门户网站的数据,考察了2014年至2023年期间意大利医学科学领域(第06领域)高层职位和职业晋升中的性别不平等情况,数据包括学术角色、性别、地区和科学学科领域(SSD)的详细信息。使用玻璃天花板指数(GCI)和玻璃门指数(GDI)评估性别差异。截至2023年的数据分析显示职业晋升中出现了性别反转:女性在职业生涯早期阶段占主导地位——占研究员的71.5%和研究与技术开发辅助人员职位的57.1%——但男性在高级职位中占优势,副教授占61.8%,正教授占71.8%。这一趋势在大多数SSD中都是一致的。尽管时间分析表明高层职位中的性别差异有所减少——GCI从2015年的2.3降至2023年的1.7——但所有地区的GCI值均高于1,这表明性别不平等现象仍然存在。GDI值从2015年的1.3到2023年的1.6,呈现出相当大的变化;然而,总体而言,到2023年差距有所恶化。这些发现强调了采取具体措施以提高学术界公平性和包容性的必要性。制定和实施确保所有研究人员,无论性别,都能获得平等机会和资源的倡议、计划和政策至关重要。