Suppr超能文献

通过绘画看儿童头痛:一篇叙述性综述与一个人像画廊

Children's Headache Through Drawings: A Narrative Review and a Portrait Gallery.

作者信息

Ferro Floriana, Gaspari Caterina, Manfrè Giulia, Cernigliaro Federica, D'Agnano Daniela, Panzica Ruben, Correnti Edvige, Ruta Maria Rosita, Marchese Francesca, Pitino Renata, Capizzi Mariarita, Santangelo Giuseppe, Versace Antonella, Sciruicchio Vittorio, Raieli Vincenzo

机构信息

Child Neuropsychiatry Unit Department, Pro.MI.S.E. "G. D'Alessandro", University of Palermo, 90127 Palermo, Italy.

Child Neuropsychiatry Department, Istituto Mediterraneo di Eccellenza Pediatrica, ARNAS Civico, 90127 Palermo, Italy.

出版信息

Life (Basel). 2025 Jun 23;15(7):996. doi: 10.3390/life15070996.

Abstract

Headache represents one of the most prevalent and disabling conditions in the pediatric population, with significant repercussions on mental and psychological well-being, as well as on academic achievement and social functioning, ultimately leading to a marked reduction in quality of life. Currently, the diagnosis of headache is based on the clinical criteria of the third edition of the International Classification of Headache Disorders (ICHD-3). However, the characteristics of headache may differ between adults and children, as well as the ability of children to provide a complete description of the pain and associated symptoms. The immature narrative skills of children can represent a limitation in defining the clinical phenotype of headache, making the diagnosis more complex. This is even more challenging when extracting information about the characteristics of the headache in children whose verbal expression is poorly developed or completely absent. Given these limitations, clinical psychology has long used drawing as an effective diagnostic instrument to bypass verbal communication barriers. This tool provides unique access to children's psychological and emotional states, as a direct window into their inner world and as an expressive medium that often generates more detailed, accurate, and clinically actionable information, compared to verbal reports alone. For these reasons, drawing has been recognized as a valuable diagnostic tool for decades, with multiple studies demonstrating specificity and accuracy rates comparable to standard clinical assessments. Particularly for young children, drawings may give access to fundamental information that might otherwise remain inaccessible, thereby allowing both accurate diagnosis and individualized treatment planning. Multiple studies have highlighted and confirmed the graphic differences between representations of various types of headaches and the undeniable utility of an "artistic diagnosis" alongside the clinical one. Furthermore, the literature suggests and encourages the use of drawing in clinical practice, both in the diagnostic process and during subsequent follow-up, as an effective, enjoyable, easy-to-use, and low-cost resource. Accordingly, we propose a narrative review accompanied by a curated collection of drawings that may help identify and categorize specific correlations between graphic representations and clinical phenotypes, such as pain location, quality, intensity, association with nausea and vomiting, photophobia and phonophobia, and types of migraine aura. Our goal is to create a visual reference that can aid clinicians in the accurate interpretation of children's drawings. Additionally, we aim to promote the integration of this method into routine clinical practice to improve diagnostic precision and support a more child-centered model of care. We also hope to propose new iconographic models to further enrich the diagnostic framework.

摘要

头痛是儿科人群中最普遍且使人丧失能力的病症之一,对心理和精神健康以及学业成绩和社交功能都有重大影响,最终导致生活质量显著下降。目前,头痛的诊断基于《国际头痛疾病分类》第三版(ICHD - 3)的临床标准。然而,头痛的特征在成人和儿童之间可能有所不同,而且儿童完整描述疼痛及相关症状的能力也存在差异。儿童不成熟的叙述技巧可能会限制对头痛临床表型的定义,使诊断更加复杂。对于那些语言表达能力发育不良或完全没有语言表达能力的儿童,提取有关头痛特征的信息时,这一挑战尤为突出。鉴于这些局限性,临床心理学长期以来一直将绘画作为一种有效的诊断工具,以绕过语言沟通障碍。这个工具提供了独特的途径来了解儿童的心理和情绪状态,作为直接洞察他们内心世界的窗口,以及一种表达媒介,与单纯的口头报告相比,它往往能产生更详细、准确且具有临床可操作性的信息。出于这些原因,几十年来绘画一直被视为一种有价值的诊断工具,多项研究表明其特异性和准确率与标准临床评估相当。特别是对于幼儿,绘画可能会提供一些原本无法获取的基本信息,从而实现准确诊断和个性化治疗计划。多项研究强调并证实了不同类型头痛的图形表示之间的差异,以及“艺术诊断”与临床诊断并行的不可否认的实用性。此外,文献表明并鼓励在临床实践中使用绘画,无论是在诊断过程中还是在后续随访中,作为一种有效、有趣、易于使用且低成本的资源。因此,我们提出一篇叙述性综述,并配有精心挑选的一组绘画,这可能有助于识别和分类图形表示与临床表型之间的特定关联,如疼痛部位、性质、强度、与恶心和呕吐的关联、畏光和畏声,以及偏头痛先兆的类型。我们的目标是创建一个视觉参考,以帮助临床医生准确解读儿童的绘画。此外,我们旨在促进将这种方法整合到常规临床实践中,以提高诊断精度并支持更以儿童为中心的护理模式。我们还希望提出新的图像模型,以进一步丰富诊断框架。

https://cdn.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/blobs/12de/12298764/3e257eb23314/life-15-00996-g001.jpg

文献检索

告别复杂PubMed语法,用中文像聊天一样搜索,搜遍4000万医学文献。AI智能推荐,让科研检索更轻松。

立即免费搜索

文件翻译

保留排版,准确专业,支持PDF/Word/PPT等文件格式,支持 12+语言互译。

免费翻译文档

深度研究

AI帮你快速写综述,25分钟生成高质量综述,智能提取关键信息,辅助科研写作。

立即免费体验