Somohano Vanessa C, Vasquez Alicia E, Shank Taylor, Irrgang Makenzie, Newman Aurora G, Evans Cameron, Wyse Jessica J, Denneson Lauren, O'Neil Maya, Lovejoy Travis
VA Portland Health Care System.
Pacific University.
Cogn Behav Pract. 2024 Feb;31(1):48-57. doi: 10.1016/j.cbpra.2022.05.003. Epub 2022 Jun 22.
Women with comorbid posttraumatic stress disorder (PTSD) and substance use disorder (SUD) demonstrate the greatest psychiatric severity when entering mental health treatment, and poorest rates of treatment completion and relapse compared to those with either disorder alone. Mindfulness-based interventions (MBIs) for women with comorbid PTSD-SUD may be an effective treatment approach as it targets mechanisms underlying self-medication of trauma-related symptoms via substance use. Little is known, however, of the benefits of MBIs for this population. Thus, the purpose of this study was to qualitatively elucidate mechanisms of action in a pilot MBI adapted for women with comorbid SUD and PTSD, with the goal of identifying the most salient aspects of MBIs that target self-medication of PTSD symptoms via substance use. Following completion of a trauma-integrated MBI, women (N = 39) diagnosed with PTSD-SUD were invited to attend one of ten, 60-minute, audio-recorded focus groups. A semistructured interview protocol was utilized to investigate how participants perceived the utility of MBIs in mitigating PTSD and SUD symptoms over the course of the intervention. Conventional content analysis guided qualitative analysis and reporting. Participants described four mechanisms through which they experienced MBIs attenuating the relationship between PTSD and SUD: increased attention to trauma- and substance-related triggers occurring in the present moment; greater cultivation of nonjudgmental acceptance to aversive experiences; development of self-compassionate attitudes toward suffering; and increased tolerance to aversive experiences. Building upon these mechanisms of action, we propose a moderated mediation model, in which increased present-moment awareness, nonjudgmental attitudes toward distress, and self-compassion reduce impulsivity and negative affect, which then increases tolerance for aversive experiences, thereby attenuating the relationship between PTSD and SUD symptoms. Interventions targeting the four proposed mechanisms may be considered when treating women diagnosed with comorbid PTSD-SUD.
患有创伤后应激障碍(PTSD)和物质使用障碍(SUD)的女性在进入心理健康治疗时表现出最严重的精神症状,与仅患有其中一种障碍的女性相比,治疗完成率和复发率最低。针对患有PTSD-SUD的女性的正念干预(MBIs)可能是一种有效的治疗方法,因为它针对通过物质使用自我治疗创伤相关症状的潜在机制。然而,对于这一人群MBIs的益处知之甚少。因此,本研究的目的是定性阐明一种适用于患有SUD和PTSD的女性的试点MBI的作用机制,目标是确定MBIs中通过物质使用针对PTSD症状自我治疗的最显著方面。在完成一项创伤综合MBI后,邀请39名被诊断患有PTSD-SUD的女性参加十个60分钟的录音焦点小组之一。采用半结构化访谈协议来调查参与者如何看待MBIs在干预过程中减轻PTSD和SUD症状的效用。传统内容分析指导定性分析和报告。参与者描述了她们体验到MBIs减轻PTSD和SUD之间关系的四种机制:对当下发生的与创伤和物质相关的触发因素的关注度增加;对厌恶经历的非评判性接纳的更多培养;对痛苦形成自我同情的态度;以及对厌恶经历的耐受性增加。基于这些作用机制,我们提出了一个调节中介模型,其中当下意识的增强、对痛苦的非评判态度和自我同情减少了冲动性和负面影响,进而增加了对厌恶经历的耐受性,从而减轻了PTSD和SUD症状之间的关系。在治疗被诊断患有PTSD-SUD的女性时,可以考虑针对所提出的四种机制的干预措施。