The foreign body response (FBR) is a complex and multifaceted process that remains incompletely understood, often leading to complications in medical device integration. In this study, we constructed a literature-based network of the FBR and developed it into a semi-quantitative predictive model to better understand its dynamics. The FBR model incorporates key material-related factors, including immunogenic properties and mechanical mismatch, which influence immune cell activation and extracellular matrix (ECM) deposition. Predictions align with existing knowledge, showing that material stiffness and tissue progressive stiffening due to increased ECM deposition can exacerbate the FBR and that feedback interactions can protect the system from pathological outcome by gradually reducing the initial inflammatory input. The model also successfully replicated six out of eight experimental cases of anti-fibrotic interventions, demonstrating its potential as a predictive tool. Assessing implant safety in the early pre-clinical stages of device development is critical for ensuring long-term functionality and reducing adverse reactions. By systematically analyzing and integrating all interacting aspects of the FBR, modeling can provide valuable insights and complement and studies for improved implant safety assessment.