Breivold Jørgen, Rø Karin Isaksson, Nilsen Stein, Hjörleifsson Stefán
Department of Global Public Health and Primary Care, University of Bergen, PO Box 7804, Bergen, N-5020, Norway.
The Norwegian Medical Association, Institute for Studies of the Medical Profession, Oslo, Norway.
BMC Prim Care. 2025 Aug 2;26(1):240. doi: 10.1186/s12875-025-02928-5.
Choosing Wisely is an international initiative to curb medical overuse. The Norwegian College of General Practice has published recommendations to avoid commonly used services for safer healthcare. This study investigated Norwegian GPs' perceptions of Choosing Wisely.
Cross-sectional online survey of Norwegian GPs in 2021. We report GPs' perceptions of Choosing Wisely recommendations as proportions, using multiple ordinal regression to assess factors influencing the campaign's perceived usefulness.
Responses from 900 GPs, with a response rate of 18% were included. 81% were aware of Choosing Wisely, and of these 82% found the campaign somewhat or very useful in reducing overdiagnosis or overtreatment. This correlated with lower levels of work-related stress (adjusted odds ratio (AOR) 0.61, 95% confidence interval (CI) 0.45-0.83) and more frequently reaching an agreement with patients to avoid unnecessary medical activities (AOR 1.93, 95% CI 1.26-2.95). More frequently reaching agreement with patients was also associated with finding the campaign very useful (AOR 2.21, 95% CI 1.51-3.24). Among those who did not find the campaign useful, 74% stated that this could partly be due to the campaign's inability to influence patients' opinions. 90% of the GPs who were aware of the campaign had implemented one or more recommendations.
Choosing Wisely appears to be considered useful by a substantial proportion of Norwegian GPs. Since the effectiveness of the campaign seems to be linked to the ability to manage gatekeeping, it may be beneficial to bolster the gatekeeping role of GPs and raise public awareness of medical overuse.
“明智选择”是一项旨在遏制医疗过度使用的国际倡议。挪威全科医生学院发布了相关建议,以避免使用常用服务来实现更安全的医疗保健。本研究调查了挪威全科医生对“明智选择”的看法。
2021年对挪威全科医生进行横断面在线调查。我们以比例形式报告全科医生对“明智选择”建议的看法,并使用多元有序回归来评估影响该活动感知有用性的因素。
纳入了900名全科医生的回复,回复率为18%。81%的人知晓“明智选择”,其中82%的人认为该活动在减少过度诊断或过度治疗方面有些或非常有用。这与较低的工作相关压力水平相关(调整后的优势比(AOR)为0.61,95%置信区间(CI)为0.45 - 0.83),并且更频繁地与患者达成避免不必要医疗活动的共识(AOR为1.93,95%CI为1.26 - 2.95)。更频繁地与患者达成共识也与认为该活动非常有用相关(AOR为2.21,95%CI为1.51 - 3.24)。在那些认为该活动无用的人中,74%表示这部分可能是由于该活动无法影响患者的意见。知晓该活动的全科医生中有90%实施了一项或多项建议。
相当一部分挪威全科医生认为“明智选择”是有用的。由于该活动的有效性似乎与守门能力相关,加强全科医生的守门作用并提高公众对医疗过度使用的认识可能会有所帮助。